Ereignis: 0, (Max.: 500+)

[...]mporality
+
a mode of continuity with an era that was already nostalgic for the unrealized transformative potential (of real socialism)


(Yurchak's) *frozen present* = the time of nostalgia
}<== late socialist culture itself lived in a nostalgic mode, at a certain ironic, knowing distance from what it was supposed to be according to the memories of the heroic 40s-50s and the remnants of socialist propaganda --> *a familiar ironic mode of experiencing history vicariously* (in a way that is experienced in the imagination through the actions of another person)


(looking at televisual nostalgia -->) late socialism ==> an affect and'>& epistemology that can only access the “authentic” through contradiction ambivalence self-reflective irony
<--Holdsworth-- expression of present anxieties about history and memory in general

...................................

___[notes Tehran 2023]___

semiotics: study of the differnce between “what you say ~/= what they understand

(my fundamentals:)
*sharing =/= communicating*


آشپز دیو سپید
it is said that the White Div had a cook --> exploring the cosmology of Div (in Shahnameh) with food, hunting for eating, bestiary, cooking technology, taste
(inspired by anime JYfdfDU9JUY)
#short story: narrartor describes the story after the defeat of the White Div (Div-e Sefid) by Rostam. “rather than worring about the kingsmen X, he was more interested in what is for dinner...”. there is another being. a baby hayula (non-formity)... what other beings Div hunts for meat? (list, bestiary) “he would think about the next hunt X and get excited about the kabab of X...”  “immediately asked for more”

landscape cartography mapping affect architecture narrative space heaven paradise sky God environment embodiment technique [source: Sina Seifee] dungeons and dragons --> a non-cartographic space, there are no maps and one only learns by dying many times
dungeon has nothing to do with the medieval prison, it is a deterritorialized habitat, defined precisely by not having a map (or guide) --> are we in a dungeon?

...................................

journalism: professional discursive pursuit (of truth, of propaganda, etc.)
=/= journalism: proximity to the event + the risks that that entails

(Ghazzi's notion of) *affective proximity* : (a mode of consideration, a way) to make sense of local media practitioners’ reporting and witnessing of suffering in their country
--> a media practitioner =/= the event they are representing and participating in
affective proximity : what locals navigate to reconcile their emotional and embodied entanglement within events in their country =/= discursive

*emotional labour* of media practices of local reporters and witnesses

what the word “revolution” mediates (in Syria, Iran, etc.) [~/?= civil war]
1. an indication of commitment to a desired goal
2. an identity marker based on a past-oriented lament over what was sought but not achieved

study of affect and emotion in global news --(contextualized within)--> unequal power relations (==> journalistic roles and'>& modes ofrepresentaiton)

user-generated-content
political economy of global war reporting
living with violence

journalism <--?---> affect

affective proximity
==shape==> the boundaries of journ0alism and activism
--> captures the feeling of being close to violence:
fear for one's life and that of others
having to deal emotionally logistically with deaths of loved ones (escape, exile) [--> that is why we need an *anthropology of the exile*]
}--> living-in-violence =/= encounter, exposure

(Ghazzi is too fast in favoring “affective proximity =/= western rationalism”, as an iranian I am more exposed to an *affective jurnalism* [~= activism: politically motivated and highly emotive role] =/= journalism as a modernist and rationalist institution)
“activism ~= jurnalism” ~=> they need to:
1. project authenticity and emotion onto news narratives
2. act as objective witnesses able to produce truthful accounts

(more and more i feel the iranians need for ‘activism =/= jurnalism’ --> what one wants to happen =/= understanding what is happening)--> epistemology [the question of how one makes sense of one's practices --> in the case of Syria (also Iran): *affective proximity to violence* ==> sense]

...negotiating the distance of mediation when viewers and producers in the Global North are witnessing the suffering of others

(in Iran) activism + art = the human body as tool, medium, symbol, metaphor

[*]affect: circulation + stickiness of emotion (onto and between bodies, texts, objects, experiences) (Ahmed)

journalism = represent + narrate

(the ‘trick’ of) relying on the *outsourcing of emotional labour* to non-journalists (by:)
having them express their emotions
having the journalist describe them

(Ghazzi conceptualising the emotional field in journalism -->) ***unequal power relations ==> emotioal labor***

proximity (--> what i heard so much when i went back to iran: to ke inja insti nemiduni تو که اینجا نیستی نمیدونی)

*aesthetic of authenticity* in news reports (<-- mobile phones)
political economy of foreign reporting
politics of hope (with an ambition to inspire all Syrians to rebel)
...emotional attachment to political goals


*revolution: the event that changes people's lives and in relation to which they locate themselves politically
conflict in Syria began as an uprising, it ended up an international war, which in 2020 appears to have mostly concluded in the favour of the regime =/= revolution
the word “revolution” means something else to activists in Syria (how the meanings projected on the term changed in accordance to circumstances)
(most of the time, artists and activists) ****use a word to galvanise their emotions and bodies**** and inspired them to take actions they would not have imagined to pursue [use of words --> what people hope =/= descriptive]
word (for example “revolution”): a marker of an *inward-looking description* of belonging to a broad political community defined by opposition
“the revolution” --> affectively consumed the pursuit of truth
an identity-marker (based on a political orientation) --> an inward-looking signifier to mark who one is + what political community they belong to [--> a politics of what one had wanted =/= describe what one observes]
(revolution:) personified and humanised as a well-meaning political agent (that sometimes strays from its goals by committing errors)
motivating people to get involved in activism


(Said's Orientalism -->) subaltern others (are typically considered) living within a constant state of violence <-- much older Western regime of representation perceived them as culturally close to violence

(Ghazzi > Badiou >) some events are felt as historic as they galvanise the energies of political actors who imagine themselves as ‘mounting the stage of history’ --Koselleck--> acts of information dissemination are engulfed by the event and are aimed at bridging the temporal distance between the desired and experienced ==> “journalism ~= activism”

...................................

collective memory --> historical victimhood --> consolidating power
(meta-history -->) a view of history as a series of junctures where good fought evil ==Ghazzi==> historical victimhood

global rise of populist politics ==> tropes of self-victimisation
revolutionary
resistance
nationalism
populism
neo-fascism
}--> operationalize victimhood (by whom / against whom)

one is wronged, targeted, injured (by the elite, the media, external enemies)
self = true underdog --> victim
opponents = inauthentic adversary --> oppressor
= homogeneous + antagonistic
--Laclau--> chain of equivalence: (from) corruptions =/= origins --to--> traitors =/= patriots --to--> intruders =/= natives --to--> faithless =/= faithful --to--> *submission  =/= heroism* and ...
}= *populism* (political dialectic)

Wunderkammer exhibition collection environment writing [source: Alison and Peter Smithson et al., Parallel of Life and Art]cat butt ass moral erect [source: Thomas of Cantimpré, Liber de natura rerum, France ca. 1290 (Valenciennes, Bibliothèque municipale, ms. 320, fol. 72r)]ajayeb form tiger animal snake [source: Cambridge Online University Library] (storytelling)
the question of *what* a society remembers -->{highly formulaic plot structures --for--> narrating the past}
the question of *how* a society remembers -->{powerful actors push for particular kinds of story forms that shape the ways they tell all stories}

animating power footnote feeling metamorphic transformation desire think imagine attention difference worlding interruption story [source: Adilnor Collection - al-Jawahir al-Khams]wonder technology exhibition media image world system planet fuse [source: Frank Vincentz / Wunder des Sonnensystems, Ausstellung im Gasometer Oberhausen] zigzag structures of a rise and fall and/or fall and rise of the nation
--> future dramatically takes one of two routes: (in the direction of) either a golden age or the dark ages
}--Ghazzi--> forked historical consciousness : (an understanding and'>& speaking of) “history = a series of junctures scattered across time”


elephant seal baby water body assemblage camera [source: Jane Dawson] (the problem is) ***historical consciousness*** --> orientational
“bestows upon actuality a temporal direction, an orientation that can guide action intentionally by the agency of historical memory” (Rüsen)
1. make specific references to historic events (compare them to the present [==guide==> political action])
2. *making references to “history” at large*

Iran flower Sa'di war poetry literature proximity metaphysics [source: Shahram Razavi] [*]zigzag memory structure: deploy mnemonic spins to reframe historic events
establish equivalent between the present and the past [--!--> (fundamentally despotic?) technique that i also use in lecture performances]


authoritarian populism


(Hegelian) [*]action: pursue one aspect of history + breaking away from away from another
1. (modern) revolutionary: telling a new story, (--populist--> focus on) *exclusionary politics*, once the leader is in power the objective is to prolong the idea of historic juncture --justify--> continued exclusion

nature material computation dell science knowledge representation microscope zoom [source: http://www.nature.com/] populist --Laclau--> (invocation of)
people = empty signifier
leader = embodiment of people's agency

cat ass morality animal erect [source: Bestiary, England 15th century (København, Kongelige Bibliotek, GkS 1633)] ***rhetoric of resentment*** --> victimhood
[*]resentment: an emotional-moral framework --aim--> continuously regenerate the felt intensities --underwrite--> demands for revenge + lamentations (of victimhood)


***nationalism ==> populism***

interference animal jewellery treasure ganj mountain force intensification material plane intra-action percept media data plot [source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Prachtk%C3%A4fer_aus_der_Grube_Messel.JPG] (many countries) national identity (& militancy) is intertwined with:
narrative of self-victimization --
invocation of trauma

wonder story assemblage composition affect tale report whirlpool animal media techne waterbody fish [source: NOAA] victorious victimhood ==fuels==> aggressive militancy
for example --> Israel: nothing counts as evidence as one's own empowerment, one is always under threat, if Israel cannot maintain the omnipotent position that its victory offered (1967) it would be under existential threat

anticolonial nationalism (or postcolonial populism)
past injury (“We have been oppressed” ==> “re-empower ourselves again”)
decades after independence --still--> fixated on the anticolonial moment ==> perpetuate a sense of victimhood }--> to mask authoritarianism

documentary history storytelling journey mind universe cartography [source: Cosmos (TV Series 2014)] victimhood
Hindu nationalism --> reformulated history from a focus on colonialism and postcolonial nation-building into a narrative of victimhood that blames historic Muslim invasions for the decline of Hindu civilisation and nationhood
China --> reformulated its school history textbooks to stress victimhood and humiliation through the idea of China's “100 years of humiliation” in reference to Western and Japanese invasions
United States --> nationalism often takes the shape of antipathy to government that is enmeshed with an ideology of liberal individualism

}--> ***logic of empowerment*** (--permeate--> economies of visibility)


polaritons  layered two-dimensional materials [source: http://www.nature.com/nmat/journal/v16/n2/full/nmat4792.html] ***memory narrative***


iran --> shohada شهدا martyrs of iran-iraq war --> after the war became the picture of collective victimhood (“heroes = us”)

Europe union science technology visualization identity image map [source: Kurzgesagt] Erdogan's speech
“we have been tested by fire” (--?--> Siavash's fire trial is populist?)
~= “we have been tested by enemy”
~= “evil forces”


(from) populism --to--> neofascism
(from) generic rhetoric of an unidentified enemy --to--> articulation of an identifiable foe (who is met with political violence)

animal pig wolf dog nature ajayeb matter becoming articulation people [source: Harmen Jansz. Muller ca. 1540 - metmuseum.org] authoritarian state apparatus [= political system + culture + institutions + ?] --allow--> smoother way of operationalisation of narratives (about the dangers of adversaries)
-exactly what kind of state apparatus we have in iran?


historical victimhood --> resurgent populist discourse
people have been enduring victimhood for too long
fateful junctures throughout history
authentic great path
urgency of message


animating rhetoric with self-victimhood ==produce==> divisions (men =/= women, us =/= enemy, etc.)



Culebra viperina snake lake forest trickster wonder intra-action human anthropos assemblage plot [source: depaseoporlanaturaleza.blogspot.be] exclusionary politics <-- homogeneous community (=/= alien intrusion, outside forces, immigrants, minorities, etc.)

...................................

anthropos wonder body human monster marvel [source: Ambroise Pare - On Monsters and Marvels] Kundera
is humor modern?
*humor is not ancient* (?!)
“whatever humor touches it ambiguites”
humor = ambiguitor

...................................

movement worlding passing technology network life survive house detour translate device metamorphic [source: Jono Podmore] globalization =/= cold war
globalization =/= enlightenment (“universal humanism + rationalized tech ==> freedom for all”)

cold war = a meaningfull relation between ideology and'>& power [==give==> orientation + identity --> normative approach to global phenomena]
geopolitc + ideologic borders
=/=
globalization --> completly different political behaivor (definitions of national goals, friend and enemy, etc.) --> pluralist democracy (differences + contrasts) =/= social democracy (erasing differences)

wonder story assemblage composition affect tale report whirlpool animal media techne tail [source: reed-cpa.com] globalization = attitude حالت =/= meaning
[cold war:world ~= (a sort of) problem” --> behaviors had] meaning ==> (base for) power

optic visuality system Enlightenment measurement phenomenon [source: physics.kenyon.edu] cold war: war ==> identities
globalization: conflits =/=> identities

...................................

two points
artistic research: a form of art that uses knowledge as its main medium
artistic research has no relation to the unknown (=/= an idea of research im in which one faces something unknown or new therefore needs to research)
my work (in general) has been about the critique of engineering (the talent of engineering)


Eocene mammalian selves self minor celestial impact world now time species storytelling [source: Esther van Hulsen] ...................................

thinking with traps [working title]
Allow me to make you a trap. I think traps and lures are interesting to think with when one is oriented toward a nontransportive investigative work. What I mean by nontransportive investigative work is a mode of approach to “getting to know” something [*call it research] where your subject does not speak plain to you, and you, nor your work, do not intend to transform them. The question of “what is interesting for them?” raises up immediately. This question emerges in all sorts of domains of social life. As a bullshiter [*a technical term for performance-lecture: an art of interweaving logos] and program-coordinator and educator in the art sector (ZUYD Toneelacademie Maastricht), I am permanently positioned to ask this question. For this I have found the notion of trap particularly useful to think with, especially in environments where participants entice each other in their subjects of knowledge by means of an adaptable cunning intelligence.


woman horse text dragon assemblage [source: Gottingen University Library] Somewhere between fairytale findings, animal associations, and dictations from Benjamin Alberti, Eva Hayward, Marcel Detienne, and Vinciane Despret, I am thinking about traps as zoo-anthropo-biomorphic artifacts, made-up things that entice meaning across species. Trap-making is the forms of knowledge of the back-tracking of a fox, of building a fishing net, skills of a weaver, a carpenter, polymorphism of an octopus, and the rhetorical tricks of a crafty charlatan. The trap-maker imagines what is the perspective of a radically different being. If you make a trap for other animals you are fully engaged in multi-species perspectival game. You think about their bodies engaged in a perspectival communication. I argue, lures are needed to convey meaning. In this sense, lures and traps are mimetic devices, they are enticements of meaning, and we have mimetic participation with them. Mimetic is the opposite of semiotic. In mimetic participation, one does not ponder about the symbolic relations hidden in the game, but rather one is caught in its form. But this form can still be meta and not literal. In my understanding and use of lure one is not necessarily fossilized by this seizure. It is a form of figuration by trying to enact. It demands enacting something outside of you. A mimetic preoccupation is something that you cannot stop following. [*The fashion industry, marketing, conspiracy theories, art, psychology, and hunting, are all about mimesis.]


One mimetic form that I have been caught in is an old figure of children's fairy tale, Cinderella--during her confinement with the evil step-mother and two step-sisters. Cinderella is my ancestor and heritage. I was exposed as a child to Disney’s version of Grimm’s recollection of the story, which was the very last Disney movie that was officially dubbed in Farsi before the Iranian revolution. Cinderella’s voiceover in Farsi was the continuum of an actor-training that originated in the Tehrani cabaret voice-performances. Her voice has a radically different feeling than its English original. In contrast to how “childish” the mice sounds in the movie, Cinderella's articulations are perceived much more “adult,” sexually textured, of how a young female sounded like in the Iranian consumer culture of the 1950s. Recollecting that Cinderella now reveals something else that corresponds with my research, an attic bestiary, a mini universe of meanings and beings with whom she is in conversation with and in a permanent collaboration of worlding.


cosmology world [source: https://fineartamerica.com/] Cinderella lives with the precarity of a family who torment and insult her on a daily basis. I kept asking myself, why doesn't she become estranged? Cinderella is circumscribed in all sorts of ways, yet she is capable of knowing new things about the animals she lives. She incorporates a form of transhumanity that lies in (1) the way she is inhabiting and composing with a place that she is not a master of nor can she escape from, and (2) in the way animals give her power and meaning. Can we think of Cinderella as an amateur ethologist? A skilled practitioner of attention to animals, for whom the ways that attention is addressed matters. A Cinderella who does her job is bizarre. It engages us in a totally different manner than a Cinderella who is the victim of evil circumstances. Not considered as a victim, she becomes much more present, inviting more interesting questions about her labor of knowledge production. This opened for me a space to think about her inhuman gesture of endurance, her know-how of being in a world that proliferates with chaotic zones of improvisation with animals. From Cinderella one can learn cross-species politeness and exploring ways of imagining what animals are capable of, with and because of her labor. This is her mice-trap. Steeped in routines of schizo-affective hallucinating with talking animals, her technique of trap-making is not a category of human behavior, but a model for a form of intelligence. I argue that as a lover and interlocutor of mice, her traps are in the form of a net in which her subject becomes entangled. Lures are frequently needed to prompt meaning to an animal. Cinderella to the mice, is an alluring producer of sociality. Her mice-trap produces the meaning of the social. The mouse is captured not as prey but as material comrade and ally.


[....]


shahname Ferdosi Div Rostam pit kill articulation agon [source: Adilnor Collection] Sometimes there is no maker behind the trap. They are created by the world, by random, emergent, coalescence of elements in the environment. In a witness-fable by Kelileh o Demneh we have a moment of problematization of cunning intelligence. The story goes, once a fox was walking down his forest when he noticed animals were escaping from something. Upon further investigation he found out they were running from a special sound that scared them, a loud drum. At this stage, he is curious but vigilance and not afraid, because he knows the forest is all deceit and trickery. His inner thought is opportunistic or playful, he thinks there must be something juicy there that I can get my hands on. Lured in the other direction than other animals, he goes to the source of the sound, and puts his paws in it. He realizes that the sound was created by the force of wind moving a tree branch to hit the remains of an animal fat and skin caught in the branches. Disappointed and victorious, he calls the illusion and moves on. Here we have the fox revealing the techne of the lie: an assemblage of skin, fat, tree, and wind, that others are trapped in. What is the problem with the fox? What kind of wit or intelligence does he possess? Is the fox detached from the mimesis of the forest? How do we not get caught in certain traps? My question here is, in which context do you say yes to the trap?


The fox of Kelileh o Demneh is smart, someone who embodies “metis.” Metis is ancient Greek for wiley intelligence. Metis [pointed out by Detienne] refers to patterns of thought relating to an effective adaptable cunning, the exact opposite of contemplating about unchanging essences. The art of metis encompasses a coherent body of mental attitudes and intellectual behaviors that cultivates shohood (intuition شهود), makr (cunning مکر), ferasat (perspicacity فراست), farib (dissimulation فریب), badiheh (improvisation بدیهه), hushiar (vigilant attention هوشيار), be-ja (timeliness بجا). In the world of Kelileh o Demneh you are a hunter and the world is made of traps and animals are full of cunning. This is precisely the metis’ field of operation, a world of movement and ambiguity in the battle of perspectival will. For the Greeks and Kelileh o Demneh, continuous metamorphoses is the name of the game. A disconcerting divided shifting world of multiplicity that creates (1) polymorphous monsters (mistrustful mobile elusive beings) and (2) metamorphing minds (mistrustful mobile elusive minds).


cartography body image map Shiraz place [source: ] The notion of metis that we have is articulated in Greek deities powers. It is the form of knowledge of Athena, Hephaestus, Hermes, Aphrodite, Zeus, and Prometheus. The Greek gods often found themselves in either position of victory or as vanquished. Metis is the power of binding in situations of confrontation.


The fox and octopus master of bonds


Trap is polymorphism, the opposite of what it seems to be, in Greek, dolos mechanos. Dolos readers to cunning, that which is woven, braided or interlacing. It is about the ancient techniques of fitting together different pieces that articulates a whole. A skill of making knots, meshes and nets that surprise, trap and bind. A net is the invisible (mesh of) bonds, the favorite technique of metis. Bond is the combination of two things, weave and twist.

ajayeb rigs existence hierarchy snake world donya [source: Sina Seifee]
...................................

surgeon monster marvel encyclopedia curiosity human animal nature figure fish waterbody [source: On Monsters and Marvels by Ambroise Paré 1510] [*]bond = weave + twist
[*]net: invisible (mesh of) bonds <-- favorite technique of metis


arm = bond
every part of its body is a *bond* which can secure anything (but nothing can seize)


interaction urban distance measurement vision percept organism Ihde responce environment [source: galileo.rice.edu] *fox = a living bond* (can bend, unbend, reverse its own position at will)


Oppian is all about bonds, ropes, cords

...................................

Cinderella’s position neither victorious nor vanquished.


cosmography Qazwini water energy flow fluid architecure [source: Tusi - Online Cambridge University Library] I use the word “trap” because it is more problematic and dangerous than lures


[For the record, Plato completely opposed the idea of hunting with traps, because these techniques were thought to cultivate cunning and duplicity which were against what a virtuous political man should be. For Plato embodiment was a form of distraction to true knowledge.]

Qazwini ajayeb fish mermaid [source: Princeton University Library]
...................................

The cunning of “getting to know them” [...]
You politely approach in order to get to know them, research as a lure for yourself to be transformed by the encounter. The nontransportive investigation is in fact full of transformations.


It is important to think about traps not as something great and necessary, but in a sense that we should be able to recognize and choose sometimes not to do it. I think we need lures, because the world is transient, shifting, disconcerting, ambiguous, and so are we. The question always is which trap are you caught in? How does it look like? Are you alone in it? Which Cinderella is making you a trap?

wind raind text rewriting fold structure footnote palimpsest description poetry architecture stories [source: On Numerology attributed to Zosimos (d. 1100/493) / nlm.nih.gov]
...................................

________________

field, geometry, architecture, navigational space, life, line, linear, map, eye, view [source: Lynn Randolph - Living Lines] ...................................

points
* define cunning intelligence
   * greek notion of “metis” (you are a hunter: the world is made of traps and animals are full of cunning)
   * bonds --> fox + octopus
   * fox forest story kelile demne
      * is fox detached from the mimesis of the forest? Is this what critical intelligence looks like? by putting his paw and breaking that fragile assemble of skin, fat, tree, and wind. he reveals a lie. what other animals are trap engagers?
      * in which context you say yes to the trap?
* differentiate metis from Cinderella’s mouse trap (mechane, techne)
   * * trap as research method, but it has a double bind, it is as much as a lure for oneself as for the other
   *



Lucretius Nature of Things ray enlightenment index influence finger language animal bestiary anthrop [source: Michael Burghers 1682 (commons.wikimedia)] my mimetic preoccupations --> with memory


(from mnemonic devices) to mimetic devices (lure)
mimetic participation with X
(with lures and traps we have mimetic participation)


world multi species contingency assemblage human animal dog space society place [source: Peter Westenberg / constantvzw.org] a useful and necessary difference, synthesized by the Greeks--Plato and Aristotle
diegesis =/=? mimesis
(telling) -- (showing)
(recounted) -- (enacted)


you don’t get necessarily fossilized by it


cosmic order world soul woman panpsychism psyche intensity conscious potential Sadra [source: Robert Fludd] mimetic =/= semiotic
enacted showing other than you (=/= telling)
figuration by trying to imitate
to copy = mimesis + techne
(summoning =/= mimesis)
getting caught in a form
it is form, but it is not about form
industry of fashion is about mimesis
problem of realism =/= problem of mimesis

...................................

________________

mirror source knowledge embodiment filter veil tele scope sun light could unknowing raytrace [source: Ars Magna Lucis]
...................................

animating power footnote feeling metamorphic transformation desire think imagine attention difference worlding interruption story [source: Adilnor Collection - al-Jawahir al-Khams] 2. a better mouse trap
Cinderella

...................................

drawing human anthrop community sociality flow object affect media [source: Hanno Demuth] and now I tell you...
what exactly a trap is made of...
text: condensed, everything

...................................

wonder ray light water mechanism knowledge image diagram [source: Athanasius Kircher] 1. mouse trap
diary of Cinderella, a lover and interlocutor of mice
who is a mouse lover, a mouse career, a mouse interlocutor (somebody who listens and tells stories), but she is also a shepherd.
“which trap are you caught in?” is always relevant question
2. spider web




1. Benjamin Alberti
minoan culture (pottery in ancient Greek)
artifacts and appendices --> traps
2. Eva Hayward
animal thinker
transanimality
[*]trap: a mouth, a mode of utterance, the “O” curve of lips and throat that sounds out and names the apprehension of being embodied
--> ***positionality ~/= situatedness = to be trapped*** (to speak and receive ranges of sensuous input from one's environment) --> *our bodies are not endlessly available to intentionality*
3. Marcel Detienne
[*]metis: intelligence which operates in the world of becoming, in circumstances of conflict = forethought perspicacity + quickness and acuteness of understanding + trickery + deceit
[*]trap = polymorphism (the opposite of what it seems to be)
dolos mechanos
(dolos -->) [*]cunning: woven, braiding or interlacing, *fitted together* <-- ***ancient techniques that use the pliability and torsion of plant fibers to make knots, ropes, meshes and nets to surprise, trap and bind*** <-- the idea that ***many pieces can be fitted together to produce a well-articulated whole*** (~=? art)
4. Vinciane Despret




dictionary of crafts and arts (D+A)
extraordinary gesture of collecting and describing in details the skills and techniques of not the elite but the ordinary craftsman
older styles of trap-making
it is important to include the violence (asymmetry) of trap-making, that it is not a consensual relation to the other


kelile demne
indian courts to teach the young princes the art of cunning
putting your paw in the source of the thing (fat)
what is the problem with the fox?
what kind of wit or intelligence is that?
are there other ways of reading random combination of environmental elements that signal something accidental to you and orient the other animals in the forest?


moon index Iran Sa'di world refraction poiesis poetics [source: Sina Seifee] once you starting thinking with trap, you start to see them everywhere?


you are always trapped, the question is which trap are you caught in?
can it be dismantled? do you bring others in it?
do you move with the trap while being stuck in it?
which Cinderella is making you a trap?


animal build [source: thinkfreesa.com] --> a way of thinking about ways of being with technical objects without mastery or understanding them or being an engineer. we are not in a engineering relationship with traps, we are in heuristic relation with something that catches you long enough.


teasing with the negativity of traps (the entrapment)

frog  mouse crow lake human assemblage Kelile Demne [source: lithographed editions of Anwār-i Suhaylī - Kalīlah wa Dimnah - 1261] ...................................

we are not having engineering knowledge about the technicality of the object (trap), we are moved by the heuristic fascination for it.
temporarily
“the negativity of the trap:
violence of trapping
not voluntary
surprise

system cosmology hierarchy matter being planet Venus Mars Luna moon [source: Eudes Picard] ...................................

kelile demne
fox sound in forest story


we are always related, composed into something
the bullshit of “freedom”: if you’d be free, you’d have no story, no connections, no memory.
it is a kind of story that more than anyone the marketing industries today wants us to be free --> freedom is the cornerstone of consumer culture


for me: trap is at the core of understanding knowledge, of the relationship to the other, to crafts, to art


optics reflection mirror sun knowledge metaphore vision raytracing model animal image [source: Opticae Thesaurus] trap: corpus of zoo-anthropo-biomorphic artifact
the trap-maker imagining what is the perspective of radically different being
if you make a trap for other animals you are fully engaged in multi-species perspectival game
the body is fully engaged in a perspectival communication


perspectival battle of will
construction of affect
being in relation to “variety”
when you are in the business of trap-making you are in the realm of knowing different things (differential, different things that have little to do with each other)


snake animal ajayeb [source: Ibn Bakhtishu's Manafi' al-Hayawan - http://patriciapasso.com/2016/04/25/iconografia-y-significado-de-la-serpiente-en-distintas-culturas-de-oriente-y-occidente/] incite, to cite, to bring the source of others
to incite: to encourage violent behavior by unorthodox behavior

...................................

ajayeb world cosmos [source: Cambridge Online University Library] trap research
1. physical body, sensual relationship
2. (literal/virtual) abstraction: you turn the environment into an abstraction to construct something through it
1. abstraction: an erotic lure for the soul
3. mimesis: how meaning is formed
(--> propositions)


lure
in the sense of house of candy in Hansel and Gretel


kinetic kinect machine vision glitch Amazon rain forest nature culture technology interface enfold digital travel journey perception tactile reality dream surface 3D motion mimesis [source: Sina Seifee] to be able to be caught in traps, even if their are accidental, just created by random, emergent, coalescence of elements in the environment. sometimes there is no maker behind the trap.


making images as lures for my research
“making” is not an expressive medium (not a medium of communication), but a research tool
(Line) “gentle trapping towards something you want”

...................................

Despret
she asks how scientist relate to animals when they do field study
your test experiment is a form of a trap that you gain knowledge from
is there a way that we can ask the animal what interest them?


if you are investigating, how to make conjectures? conjecture: a kind of temporary hypothesis that allow you to go to the next
investigative research: your subject does not speak english to you --> what is interesting for the other


nature crystal matterial [source: http://www.nature.com/] art of the lure
art of learning from those whose enigma you are trying to solve (and have no intention in helping you)
to solve the enigma (of the raven, or the artwork of the student) --> you have to make interesting and radically speculative choices in how you produce knowledge about the work of others


fishermen and hunters, at the edge of the forest or the shore, where animals come to check out the other realms, is where they build the trap
--> fishermen and hunters are the original thinkers of this kind of intelligence, you transform knowledge by learning from animals. it is prolonged, practical, and crafty

lexicon global architecture interpreter translator standard language international diplomacy vocabulary [source: LexiconUSA]
...................................

spider
expert at waiting ---> go to Cinderella’s waiting
building environment from body liquids --> becoming bodily = the near-by-ness of things
=/= fox: suspicious

...................................

being lured into desiring and trusting <-- this is basically the game (at the school)


critique is an art that tangles with what you are proposing
fox --> lure
octopus --> best lure-engagers (they love the trap, they can’t get enough of it)

european union communicative process [source: europa.eu, Frank Toussaint]
...................................

the O
the curved lips
apprehension of that which to be embodies


scale model planet cosmology [source: Nick Strobel] to be trapped = to be situated
situatedness =/= positionality

...................................

snake serpent person reptile limb assemblage body [source: hiveminer.com] we are not fully intentionally engaged with things
what we do is not intentionally all the time

...................................

Ferdosi Shahname river water passing flow detour [source: UCB] all of this is not contextualized in adult political discourse, but I put it in children fairy tales (the Cinderella)
this is where I want the notion of trap to be situated (comprehended).

...................................

snake world [source: ]ajayeb animal leopard [source: unkown]distance grid telescope zoom measurement Ihde [source: galileo.rice.edu]web archive environmental scan wonder [source: Qazwini / ids.lib.harvard.edu]model home Heidegger pigs house building Bildung Dasein being wedge space mathematics data plot hierarchy wolf death architecture line [source: De Agostini / Getty Images]crossing technology detour existence space psychology urbanism Latour [source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Bnot_Ya%27akov_Bridge_1912.jpg]man life [source: rux.stumbleupon.com]image projection forest light table round multi-media performance security system representation hack child Linux interface predation [source: Jurassic Park movie 1993]moon wonder creation inflow follow rise [source: Qazwini book of ajayeb]Anaplastic astrocytoma Glial fibrillary acidic protein process philosophy device language [source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Anaplastic_astrocytoma_-_gfap_-_very_high_mag.jpg]rigs diagram moon finger Sa'di yar fish nakhshab reflection [source: Sina Seifee]Stromatolite stone rock fire media [source: Boston University 1984, NASA Environmental Science. Snapshot of video]fire wilderness deer heyvan animal [source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Deerfire_high_res.jpg]Triassic ecosystem marine reptiles system time relationship history [source: Henry De la Beche 1830.  University of Bristol]media literature German discourse database deutsch Sprache language computer link text Bild Ton Video station [source: widrichfilm.com]Fascia body tissue matter animal heyvan hayula terrestrial locomotion flex jell [source: anatomytrains.com]assemblage fabricate auto making path framework technology Flugblatt pamphlet encycloped [source: Zock Het Eens Op p.99]monkey animal urban city travel personhood border boundary [source: Jon Rafman]ganj earth stratum desire projection pit treasure mountain ghaf research ajayeb [source: noorbaran90.ir]stone energy field matter hayula story nunhuman agency [source: Emanuel Swedenborg]animating power footnote feeling metamorphic transformation desire think imagine attention difference worlding interruption story [source: Adilnor Collection - al-Jawahir al-Khams]Platinum crystal hayula gas material movement harkat [source: commons.wikimedia]planet, cyber, robot species, transform, interface, partial digestion, moon, 3*'1G  (.* [source: The Transformers The Movie 1986]wedge space mathematics strata Manuel Delanda data plot [source: Laura Moriarty]wonder child animal ocean assemblage species camera media photography spiderman leg strange [source: lolzhumor.com]world cosmology [source: The Gods of the Egyptians Vol. II]map cartography trajectory unknown figure diagram composition [source: Al Istakhri, Kitab al masalik wa l mamalik, Book of roads and kingdoms]Teguise Guatiza image sym life poesis poiesis biomic Haraway [source: wikipedia]wood grain Laura Marks Islamic art form techne shape force intensification [source: wikimedia]ajayeb book fish species face head body magnetism island [source: Tusi, ʿAjā'ib al-makhlūqāt wa gharā'ib al-mawjūdāt]woman laugh snake mirror abyss animal landscape morality erect nature [source: Matali' al-Saadet (The Book of Felicity)]nature material computation atom science knowledge representation zoom simulation innovation wealth Hydrogen asymmetry [source: http://www.nature.com/]allegory boat wolf eagle river wedding temperament optic Da Vinci [source: http://www.leonardodavinci.net]atlas cartography Olearius map Sa'di perspectiv tool diagram planetary shathiat [source: Sina Seifee]graph diagram species scene pleistocene sadistic science life earth data plot [source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Extinction_intensity.svg]demand child lecture speech [source: Peter Blegvad - Leviathan]wood grain form techne invention art fiber arrangement poiesis [source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Plain_quarter_sawn.png]Eocene mammalian selves self minor celestial impact world now time species storytelling [source: Esther van Hulsen]soul body image phantom limb subjectivity ego psychology topology morphology postural schema Grosz [source: USD Biology]stone human geology intensification matter flow catalog [source: Gall stones | Walz Elektronik]evidence fact model subduction trench mathematics [source: Laura Moriarty]stromatolite rock fire [source: http://www.orstentype.com/?page_id=11]cosmology world [source: https://fineartamerica.com/]animal turtle tortoise possum cat deer fish snake raccoon [source: John Lawson 1709]ouroboros snake erect mortality morality beast [source: ]water dynamic architecture space solid rigid soft flow fluid liquid society sociality heyvan [source: Der Jungbrunnen by Lucas Cranach  1472–1553]medicine writing footnote animate feeling awareness knowledge tool story [source: Kitāb al-Raḥmah fī al-ṭibb wa-al-ḥikmah (The Book of Mercy Concerned with Medicine and Wisdom) by Muḥammad al-Mahdawī ibn ‘Alī ibn Ibrāhīm al-Ṣanawbarī (d. 1412/ 815) / nlm.nih.gov]Sohrevardi cosmology angel vector animal movement evolution harkate johari rouge field force divine Islam flow mortality excess [source: Sina Seifee & many others]technology machinery hall rocket cabinet wonder wunder transportation poetry religion [source: Hall of the Rocket Machinery at Tsiolkovsky State Museum of the History of Cosmonautics in Kaluga - https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Zal_raketnoi_techniki.JPG]world multi species contingency assemblage human animal dog space society place [source: Peter Westenberg / constantvzw.org]snake person assemblage semiotics [source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Northern_Water_Snake.jpg]map worlding geometry civilization space social [source: Tavarikh Al-Osman]nature things Serres philosophy universe atom writing world [source: De rerum natura by Lucretius (c. 99 BC – c. 55 BC) / ibiblio.org/]Munes al-Abrar moon fish twelve birds taxon [source: Folio from a Mu'nis al-Abrar fi Deqa'iq al-Ash'ar / top: The Moon and Fish; bottom: Twelve different birds in 2 registers]space human technoscience monitor system control room architecture extension culture interface outer outside euro house void [source: Harald Bischoff / DLR - German Space Operations Center]rock material sensation [source: Sina Seifee 4/4/2016]mineral karibibite oumlil stone fire [source: minfind.com]Persia native scene scenic oriental frontispiece monument architecture curtain paradise [source: ]snake skin assemblage river organism environment Barad [source: Sean Gagnon (commons.wikimedia)]lens beauty decoration science telescope embodiment aesthetics ornamentation divine rich care attention encode decryption value meaning mystery [source: Galileo Galilei Objective lens, Padua, late 1609 n a frame made of ebony and ivory - Istituto e Museo di Storia della Scienza, Florence / astronomy2009.org]brittlestar intrinsic discursive predator body bodily boundary container world stage difference differential production aqua media arm [source: Wikimedia Commons]attention frigatebird media sea anthropology information [source: wikimedia, photograph by Mario Müller]sky destiny logic influence inflow intra-action environment [source: tumblr]jinn bath human architecture demon hygiene wonder book [source: Kitab al-bulhan or ajayeb mountain earth pit Sina wonder mother matter horizon name people distance [source: scan from Qaswini's Ajayeb al Makhlughat]simulation representation child human model earth world grasp understanding tangibility memory device vision science [source: Ender's Game film 2013]moon indexicality finger drawing diagram moon finger Sa'di yar fish nakhshab reflection wonder [source: Sina Seifee & many others]life earth transcendence chasing Acacia facsiculifera seedling process form endosymbiosis [source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Acacia_facsiculifera_seedling.jpg]geography language sign metamorphosis earth geomorphology semiotics [source: Upper Gotvand Dam / mehrnews.com]Galileo telescope optics affect medium interaction exteriority [source: astrofiliveronesi.it]wind fact environment affect plot story literature ajayeb wonder inflow signifier nature culture representation [source: Qaswini]map empty space progress gaze geometry exhibition speed frontispiece [source: David Teniers der Jüngere, Ansicht der Stadt Valenciennes 1656. Öl auf Leinwand, 177 x 205 cm, Koninklijk Museum voor Schone Kunsten, Antwerpen.]cosmology world [source: https://fineartamerica.com/]astronomy geography celestial cosmology tail sea water body collect abyss Andromeda Perseus beast [source: Joachim Wtewael  (1566–1638) - towerweb.net]Delphinus surgeon monster marvel encyclopedia curiosity human animal nature figure fish [source: On Monsters and Marvels by Ambroise Paré 1510]matterial substance interface [source: https://www.allegorithmic.com/products/substance-designer]Blickmaschinen gaze system visuality vision technique observer perspective situated knowledges positionality [source: Werner Nekes collection]media literature German discourse lecture space deutsch Sprache language university performance found object [source: medienpuls-bayern.de]snake star wunderkammer dichotomy lexicon taxonomy nova techne [source: Johannes Stradanus, nova reperta]elephant situated knowledges parable perspective relativism [source: http://www.tendergrassfedmeat.com/index.php?s=sammati_tarka_prakarana]cosmology angels nature history king relationship aesthetic [source: Zubdat al-Tawarikh - Luqman ibn Husayn al-Ashuri  - 1593]natural history museum Isfahan Esfehan wunderkammer visualization animal [source: commons.wikimedia]rig sort algorithm machine language series leg arm line map connect [source: stackoverflow.com/questions/18840088/advanced-sorting-algorithm]pidgin minimal unambiguous message telegraphic code  dubious literacy [source: dailymaverick.co.za]time scale model [source: Nick Strobel]Andromeda Perseus killing beast ocean form abyss tail [source: Piero di Cosimo - Liberazione di Andromeda / commons.wikimedia.org]technology war design techne episteme geometry linearity perspective architecture instrument device [source: Joost Bürgi in Heilbron, vision subject object optics visuality position apparatus organism media [source: Athanasius Kircher / Deutsche Fotothek]polaritons layered two-dimensional materials [source: http://www.nature.com/nmat/journal/v16/n2/full/nmat4792.html]sheep horn form social evolution sign meaning hand twist [source: 2011 -  S&P Weaver - Saltmarsh Ranch]home Heidegger pigs house building Bildung Dasein being [source: Xin Zhui - Lady Dais of the Han dynasty - oberlin.edu]fire ice Parinacota volcano geology time [source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Parinacota_volcano.jpg] ________________

...................................

Enrica's transcription



trap in relationship to knowledge, art

...................................

Trap is a zoo anthropo biomorphic artifact
if you make a trap for another animal, you think from trans species perspective
it is a dangerous game
a body [...]