[...]loss
ss='lgc'>}ss='lgc'>--commitmentss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> friendship, neighborliness, familial ties
large arsenal of off-color s clss="trms">joks>es about specias clss="trms"nttrm="listen,alist,ilist,llist,olist,ylist,ulist">lists> fogures of all s clss="trms">religs>ious traditions in the popular culture of the subcontinent...
sts clss="lsts lst1">•s clss="trms">horrors> s clss="trms">storiess>
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•psychological profile of mullas
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•weekly skewing of mullas
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•mulla s clss="trms">joks>es
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•cartoons
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•
sts>
political commentary ss='lgc'><ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> criticism
ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> mulla was to blame for everything that was perceived to be wrong (in Pakistan) ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>s clss="trms">pervs>asive skepticism<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls> ss='lgc'>[also in s clss="nms">Irans>ss='lgc'>]
skepticism shadows striving (<span clss='qstn'>?span>)
ss="large lg2" stl="font-size:110%">
the other of the striving muslim in Pakistanss='lgc'>:
sts clss="lsts lst1">•shadowi ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Shia
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•deceiving Ahmadi
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•bad-tempered mulla s>بدمزاجs>
sts>
mullass='lgc'>:
sts clss="lsts lst1">•Iqbal ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> ossification of the institution of ulama
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•Pakistani state ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> ossification of commentary upon Islamic texts
sts>
...everyday assertion that one's s clss="trms">religs>iousity is superior to others
mullass='lgc'> = full-fls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>d maleficent persona
skepticism of daily existence
stsrd clss="lstsrd">1. ...(they become skeptical) about his rationality and grounds for his beliefs
stsrd>
stsrd clss="lstsrd">2. ...(at some point) anything could be said or believed about him
stsrd>
stsrd clss="lstsrd">3. ...(he felt like) everyone around him had turned to s clss="trms">animals>s
stsrd>
stsrd clss="lstsrd">4. ...(he presumed) everyday life was one of illusion and appearances ss='lgc'>[ss='lgc'>-ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> <span clss='gtrw'>go tospan> s clss="nms">keliles> demne s>این همه سودا است، مجازs>ss='lgc'>]
stsrd>
ss='lgc'>}ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> actualize the potential for <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>skepticism that existed in the s clss="trms">socis>al fabric<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>
ss='lgc'>=/= chance encounter
ss='lgc'>=/= s clss="trms">pervs>asive condition
figure of the mulla ss='lgc'>[ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>~= collective fear ss='lgc'>+ revulsionss='lgc'>] ss='lgc'>--s clss="trms">traves>rsess='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> the fragmented public culture of the city
ss='lgc'>[<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>ss='lgc'>]ulamass='lgc'>: guardian, transmitter, s clss="trms">inters>preter of shari'a
ss='lgc'>+ s clss="trms">specifis>c claims of knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> uponss='lgc'>:
stsrd clss="lstsrd">1. s>تفسیرs> tafsir (commentary upon the Quran)
stsrd>
stsrd clss="lstsrd">2. s>فقهs> figh (jurisprudence)
stsrd>
stsrd clss="lstsrd">3. s>حدیثs> hadis (sayings of the prophet)
stsrd>
stsrd clss="lstsrd">4. s>کلامs> kalam (speculative theology)
stsrd>
ss='lgc'>+ (in Pakistan) personnel in mosquess='lgc'>:
stsrd clss="lstsrd">1. s>امامs> imam
stsrd>
stsrd clss="lstsrd">2. s>خطیبs> khatib (Frida sermon)
stsrd>
stsrd clss="lstsrd">3. s>قاریs> ghari
stsrd>
stsrd clss="lstsrd">4. s>موذنs> muezzin
stsrd>
mulla ss='lgc'>--derogatoryss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> one who is overzealous in upholding the letter of the shari'a
(ss='lgc'>+ additional connotationss='lgc'>:)
sts clss="lsts lst1">•ignorant master ss='lgc'>[ss='lgc'>-ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> <span clss='gtrw'>go tospan> mulla nasruddinss='lgc'>: s clss="trms">religs>ious master who gets by in life through hypocrisy and cunning ss='lgc'>+ outsmarting those of noble birth and high cultivationss='lgc'>]
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•gabza s clss="trms">agens>t (seizure of property)
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•sodomizer (one who rapes men)
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•a naive fool out of step with his time
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•
sts>
colonial politics in south Asia ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> British colonial administration in India see ulama as outdated, deliberately obscurantist, jahel ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> negative stereotype ss='lgc'>-ss='lgc'>-ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> post-colonial period
mullaismss='lgc'>:
sts clss="lsts lst1">•Pakistani state ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> fossilized state of knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> on Islam
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•Iqbal ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> mullaism ss='lgc'>=/= freedom of ijtihad
sts>
(Talal Asad ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>-->) Islamic diskursive tradition is grounded in <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>argument that anticipates resistance<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls> in the form of doubt, ins clss="trms">differens>ce, or lack of understanding ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> it employs the force of reason to bring forth the <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>willing performance of a practice<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>
ss='lgc'>}ss='lgc'>==producess='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> domain of orthodoxy (ss='lgc'>+ s clss="trms">relations>s of power)
(for ss="ppl">Naveeda) s clss="trms">anxis>ety or skepticism ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>~= sign of aspiration for striving
labbaikss='lgc'>: i am here (to follow your orders)
theatrical unteality
...animus lies in the s clss="trms">worlds>
ss='lgc'>[later hess='lgc'>] identitues this animus with thr workings of iblis (satan)
...this is a city of whispers ss='lgc'>[waswasenss='lgc'>], a city of mad possession ss='lgc'>[sharss='lgc'>], a city of deviation ss='lgc'>[ilhadss='lgc'>], a city of s clss="trms">anxis>ety ss='lgc'>[tazadzudss='lgc'>], a city of dispersion ss='lgc'>[intisharss='lgc'>]
the ability to smell oneself ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> to experience oneself as other
how public culture can ability skepticism as a s clss="trms">pervs>asive condition
mulla s clss="trms">joks>es ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">horrors> s clss="trms">storiess>ss='lgc'> = fear ss='lgc'>+ revulsion
(ss="ppl">Freudian) eruptive quality of s clss="trms">joks>es ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">joks>e erupts into everyday life as of from elsewhere
political cartoonss='lgc'>: maximum effect through a minimum of details
(mulla) s clss="trms">joks>es, s clss="trms">horrors> s clss="trms">storiess>, political cartoons ss='lgc'>--ss="ppl">Naveedass='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>exiling the foreignness within<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>
s clss="trms">storiess> ofss='lgc'>:
stsrd clss="lstsrd">1. mosque in an upscale shopping center
stsrd>
stsrd clss="lstsrd">2. sexually predictory mulla
stsrd>
ss='lgc'>}ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> (speaks ofss='lgc'>:)
stsrd clss="lstsrd">1. the perception that there were places in Pakistan where vise was allowed to grow unchecked
stsrd>
stsrd clss="lstsrd">2. the menace the ulama introduced into everyday life
stsrd>
ss='lgc'>}ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> (the effect ofss='lgc'>:)
sts clss="lsts lst1">•keeping public attention upon possible sites and s clss="trms">agens>ts of corruption
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•putting the everyday life into s clss="trms">questions> (as to whether it was what it appeared to be)
sts>
political cartoons ss='lgc'>--implyss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>-->
sts clss="lsts lst1">•Pakistanis are caught in someone else's game
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•growing unfamiliarity of Pakistan
sts>
(charges of)
sinfulness
sexual voraciousness
cunning
gluttony
political ambition
worthlessness
corruption
self-destruction
ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> continuous efforts to set the mulla outside of oneself (ss='lgc'>=/= everyday familiarity with the ulama)
<strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls>negative s clss="trms">storiess> and cartoons ss='lgc'>--expressss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> various degrees of skeptical orientation to the s clss="trms">worlds><strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls>
s clss="trms">joks>es ss='lgc'>--(descriptive s clss="trms">denss>ity)ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> full expression to skepticism
ss='lgc'>--ss='lgc'>{also in s clss="nms">Irans>ss='lgc'>}ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> making (mulla) grotesquely other ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> inconcevable to s clss="trms">imagis>ne any points of relatedness (to mulla)
sts clss="lsts lst1">•scatological s clss="trms">joks>es
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•reworking of official s clss="trms">rhetors>ic for ludic effect
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•exaggerated performance of power
sts>
ss='lgc'>}ss='lgc'>--Mbembess='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> “s clss="trms">relations>ship of conviviality with the realm of official power”
vulgarity ss='lgc'>==long-termss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>zombification of official figures<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls> (robbed of their humanity ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> they cannot be apprehended except through their caricatures)
<smlbrkr stl="display:block;white-space:nowrap;margin-bottom:-1em;overflow:hidden;">...................................smlbrkr>
ss="brkr">
to loosen some terms carefullyss='lgc'>: s clss="trms">mems>ory, form, order,
ss="large lg6" stl="font-size:124%">
ss='lgc'>[The arts of s clss="trms">mems>ory- Comparative perspectives on a mental artifact. Revised and updated by the s clss="trms">authors> ss="ppl">Carlo ss="ppl">ss="ppl">ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Severi. s clss="trms">Translats>ed by ss="ppl">Matthew ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Carey - ss="ppl">ss="ppl">ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Severi - HAU- Journal of Ethnographic Theoryss='lgc'>]
s clss="trms">mems>ory as a domain of s clss="trms">socis>al life
archive
“order” constitutes a principle to engender other forms of knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>
totem poles, simply records the s clss="trms">differens>t circumstances that marked a particular s clss="trms">socis>al group, were comprised of organized series
occupied with the transs clss="trms">missions> of ‘names’, but necessarily, paralleled by a form of logical power, implies sequential ordering of s clss="trms">differens>t forms of knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>.
the “art of s clss="trms">mems>ory” applies s clss="trms">differens>t types of s clss="trms">relations>ships or archival s clss="trms">techns>iques that are not limited to mere numerical calculationss='lgc'>: mnemonic, iconographic, and logical s clss="trms">techns>iques.
provide a convincing account of the complex process of ordering
in a s clss="trms">meass>ured s clss="trms"nttrm="righ,rigo,riga,rigi,trig,rign">rigs>orous way...
what characterizes the s clss="trms">syss>tem
development of taxonomic principle
s clss="trms">syss>tem endowed with a high degree of logical power
ss='thdf'>the idea of pure quantity, based on decimal numbers applicable to wide range of s clss="trms">categs>oriesss='lgc'>: people, objects, units of time or space, etc.
an “art of s clss="trms">mems>ory” possessed of rudimentary form of visual salience and an extremely complex ordering of res clss="trms">presens>table knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>
what s clss="trms">matters>s are s clss="trms">syss>tem's logical implications and not its visual manifestations
salience
(colors, shapes of knots, s clss="trms">folds>s)
the qualitative s clss="trms">categs>ories (meant to be named)
(finding) the organizing principles
precisely calibrated
oriented space
(s clss="trms">geomes>trically<span clss='qstn'>?span>)
what constitutes the logical poles of the vast spectrum of the projects in the archive (people, objects, units of time or space, etc.)
(concerning the archive) we can negotiate two types of knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>ss='lgc'>: s clss="trms"nttrm="listen,alist,ilist,llist,olist,ylist,ulist">lists>s and s clss="trms">narrats>ives
to identify a series of key elements that allow us to rethink a wider chronology
textual archaeology - evaluates and decrypts, layer by layer
discovering (evidential) mnemonically oriented means of organizing traditional knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>
(Montesinos's s clss="trms">books>ss='lgc'>:) “s clss="trms"nttrm="listen,alist,ilist,llist,olist,ylist,ulist">lists> of one hundred kings”
should we abandon the conventional terms of “s clss="trms">narrats>ive”
the term s clss="trms">narrats>ive used to describe mnemonically oriented s clss="trms"nttrm="listen,alist,ilist,llist,olist,ylist,ulist">lists>s of names..
s clss="trms">narrats>ive was just one of several s clss="trms">differens>t means of organizing knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>..
graphical res clss="trms">presens>tation, capable of developing further degrees of complexity
“form”
recreate the ‘form’ (form ss='lgc'>: ‘state of organization of s clss="trms">matters>’)
within (this/a) variable s clss="trms">syss>tem
“text” as sequences of cords
s clss="trms">mems>orization (the creation of mnemonic s clss="trms">relations>) necessarily implies the modular organization of the knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> it res clss="trms">presens>ts
constitutive dualism in many forms of the art of s clss="trms">mems>oryss='lgc'>:
sts clss="lsts lst1">•order (Anordnung) and salience (Hervorspringen)
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•expressivity (and power)
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•ens clss="trms">cods>ing (Verschlüsselung) and evocation (Herbeirufen)
sts>
possible course between the twin rocks of s clss="trms">writs>ingss='lgc'>: “s clss="trms">socis>al” and “arbitrary”
at the end it is the mental operation
(s clss="trms">techns>iques of thought)
the image plays a central role in the construction of s clss="trms">relations>s between (visual) themes and particularity of words, which in turn help organize s clss="trms">narrats>ives
<smlbrkr stl="display:block;white-space:nowrap;margin-bottom:-1em;overflow:hidden;">...................................smlbrkr>
these all were s clss="trms">techns>ical or formal s clss="trms">questions>s so far
s clss="trms">mems>ory is a way consistency maintains itself
civil s clss="trms">socis>ety is afraid of personal recollections and s clss="trms">pervs>erse s clss="trms">datas>bases, digital collections
is khm’s archive a state sponsored s clss="trms">mems>orialization, monuments of a consistent s clss="trms">histos>ry<span clss='qstn'>?span> (that assumes a s clss="trms">sublims>e ending<span clss='qstn'>?span>)
the ims clss="trms">mems>orial (in s clss="trms">mems>orial)
have a strong philosophy of s clss="trms">techns>ology with this project
there is never merely a s clss="trms">techns>ological s clss="trms">questions>, always als clss="trms"nttrm="already,spread">reads>y s clss="trms">ontos>logical
who wants to res clss="trms">mems>ber, solidify, and s clss="trms">mems>orialize<span clss='qstn'>?span>
and for whom<span clss='qstn'>?span>
building a s clss="trms">techns>ological temple of s clss="trms">mems>ory, khm s clss="trms">aesthets>ic s clss="trms">narrats>ive of its own s clss="trms">histos>ry<span clss='qstn'>?span>
(first there is one big account of property that all these fragmented s clss="trms">histos>ries of numerous people who worked in khm are singed under one sigs clss="trms">naturs>e, of khm)
should we disavow any notion of “spirit” in khm<span clss='qstn'>?span>
we must agree that khm's render of its own s clss="trms">histos>ry is pure s clss="trms">aesthets>ic what so ever.
we must remain committed to the experimental, when dealing with archival domains in the school of media art where experimentation was in its os clss="trms"nttrm="righ,rigo,riga,rigi,trig,rign">rigs>inal conception and foundational roots (as Zielinski expresses in one s clss="trms">inters>viewss='lgc'>: “ss='lgc'>+25 KHMss='lgc'>: ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Siegfried Zielinski” https://www.youtube.com/watch<span clss='qstn'>?span>v=ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>S3JQ3aTwu2s)
arte
DAss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>S KURZFILM-MAGAZIN
KURZss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>SCHLUss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Sss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>S
ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Siegfried Zielinski im s clss="trms">Inters>view
http://cinema.arte.tv/de/artikel/siegfried-zielinski-im-s clss="trms">inters>view
hybrid objects<span clss='qstn'>?span>
is the logistic characteristic of digital s clss="trms">datas> inconsistent with the hybrid objects of art<span clss='qstn'>?span>
Forms of thought, from what Lévi-ss="ppl">ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Strauss called the “s clss="trms">syss>tematization ss='lgc'>[ofss='lgc'>] what is immediately s clss="trms">presens>ted to the senses,”
(ss="ppl">Jakobson)
transmutationss='lgc'>: cognition involved by the form of s clss="trms">translats>ion
s clss="trms">datas> s clss="trms">ontos>logy
what is the point of view of rationality in this for us<span clss='qstn'>?span>
(what is the point of view in witchs clss="trms">crafts><span clss='qstn'>?span> knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> is a performative recipe)
what is the point in point of view<span clss='qstn'>?span>
<smlbrkr stl="display:block;white-space:nowrap;margin-bottom:-1em;overflow:hidden;">...................................smlbrkr>
(ss="ppl">Jorge Luis Borges - ‘Funes the s clss="trms">Mems>orious’ in ‘Labyrinthsss='lgc'>: selected s clss="trms">storiess> <span clss='and'>&span> other s clss="trms">writs>ings’ 1964)
in Borges s clss="trms">storys>, Funes, the character unable to forget is incapable of the concept of ‘general’
solitary and lucid s clss="trms">spectas>tor of ss='lgc'>[...ss='lgc'>] an intolerably precise s clss="trms">worlds>
not capable of thought
in order to sleep, he had to s clss="trms">imagis>ne a direction he would turn his face, made of homogeneous darkness
“To think is to forget s clss="trms">differens>ces, s clss="trms">generalizs>e, make abstractions.”
Borges ‘homogeneous darkness’ is what we as forgetful immortals afraid of to turn to<span clss='qstn'>?span>
maybe the directions we sleep into, orientation to the s clss="trms">cosmos>s<span clss='qstn'>?span>!
<smlbrkr stl="display:block;white-space:nowrap;margin-bottom:-1em;overflow:hidden;">...................................smlbrkr>
is archive s clss="trms">naturs>ally and necessarily generated (out of regular form of activity)<span clss='qstn'>?span>
a (s clss="trms">techns>ologically implemented) beyond
the drive to animate and mobilize; and the drive to conserve, to fix, and so forth, are s clss="trms">mutuals>ly constitutive for s clss="trms">moderns> imagery and media (from museum to archive)
archive performs a strange dialectics
to see the archive as a s clss="trms">techns>ological rational s clss="trms">questions>, and engineering assignment, is to naively avoid the thinking about your own activity as a constructive activity
depriving yourself of any tools to act
is archive a tool to act<span clss='qstn'>?span>
the s clss="trms">agens>cy of an archive..
“other ways” of s clss="trms">composs>ing<span clss='qstn'>?span>
marking its territory<span clss='qstn'>?span> how to make a map without giving way to the territory as an extension of the map<span clss='qstn'>?span>
ss='lgc'>["Angels Without Wings” A conversation between ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bruno ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Latour and Anselm Frankess='lgc'>]
the mechanical extension, Res extensa, the (descartian) extended thing, the visualizing s clss="trms">techns>ologies, s clss="trms">techns>ical drawings, has been so strong that the temptation so say “well, that's what the s clss="trms">worlds> is really like” is very great, especially when your foreground is all of the engineering talents and engineering s clss="trms">skils>ls that are necessary to assemble.
to attribute strangeness...
what ‘will’ you ins clss="trms">herits><span clss='qstn'>?span>
you have little idea of what will you ins clss="trms">herits>
(other way of not thinking about your activity now)
<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>the s clss="trms">questions> of future
ss='lgc'>[ss="ppl">Ronellss='lgc'>]
ss="large lg34" stl="font-size:106%">
false res clss="trms">mems>brance, displaced s clss="trms">mems>ory, that actually repeatedly represses and disturbs ‘giving’
any res clss="trms">mems>brance involves forgetting
an official call for design an archive from khm also invoked that the institution is s clss="trms"nttrm="already,spread">reads>y to forget, announces institutional forgetting, and disavows res clss="trms">mems>brance
res clss="trms">mems>ber ins clss="trms"nttrm="cluster,club">clus>des the lost-s clss="trms">mems>ber, bringing my s clss="trms">mems>ber, the phalus (in English ‘s clss="trms">mems>ber’ also means the male organ of copulation)
ss='lgc'>[ss="ppl">Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich. “Das Gedächtnis.” ‘Enzyklopädie Der Philosophischen Wissenschaften Im Grundrisse’ 1817. Web.ss='lgc'>]
ss="ppl">Hegel makes a distinction of two modalities of s clss="trms">mems>oryss='lgc'>:
(1) ‘Erinnerung’ (s clss="trms">inters>nalized s clss="trms">mems>ory, which is s clss="trms">situs>ated in the heart), (it could also be s clss="trms">hallucins>atory, might dependent on an s clss="trms">inters>iority that isn't there!);
(2 and this one concerns archive) ‘Gedechnis’ (s clss="trms">techns>ological s clss="trms">mems>ory, a supplement or prosthetic device that reminds you. ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> it's mechanical, it's on the side of death and forgetting, a kind of s clss="trms">mems>ory that needs to be prompted) (to choose the s clss="trms">techns>ology of s clss="trms">writs>ing/archive the subject of s clss="trms">mems>ory is so screwed.)
<strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls>everything depends on the ways we res clss="trms">mems>ber!
ss='lgc'>[footnote on German s clss="trms">mems>oryss='lgc'>]
ss='lgc'>[blackwellreference.com, entryss='lgc'>: “s clss="trms">mems>ory, recollection and s clss="trms">imagis>nation"ss='lgc'>]
ss="ppl">Plato's doctrine that all learning is the recollection (anamnésis) of things previously known but later forgotten casts a shadow over the ideas clss="trms"nttrm="listen,alist,ilist,llist,olist,ylist,ulist">lists>s’ uses of Erinnerung.
<smlbrkr stl="display:block;white-space:nowrap;margin-bottom:-1em;overflow:hidden;">...................................smlbrkr>
is any act of res clss="trms">mems>brance also a traumatic experience<span clss='qstn'>?span> (ss="ppl">Freudian take on s clss="trms">mems>ory) ss='lgc'>-- archive is so “not” traumatic therefore a tool of amnesia. (archive in digital agess='lgc'>: the oblivion of availability ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> media theory)
can we think of a non-traumatic s clss="trms">gests>ure of s clss="trms">socis>alization of s clss="trms">mems>ory<span clss='qstn'>?span> or s clss="trms">mems>orial activity “has” to be violent in order to be res clss="trms">mems>bered<span clss='qstn'>?span> (ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">sublims>e) (like what s clss="frds scrmbld"nttrm="Alice,ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Shariati">Alis> does, tattooing me, every time he tells me one of his s clss="trms">storiess> of trauma)
like i said before, “who” wants to res clss="trms">mems>ber<span clss='qstn'>?span>
(masculinity is s clss="trms">writs>ten all over this s clss="trms">anxis>ety-ridden res clss="trms">mems>brance ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> ress='lgc'>+s clss="trms">mems>ber, bringing back the s clss="trms">syms>bolically lost phallusss='lgc'>: “s clss="trms">mems>ber” means “the male organ of copulation” in English)
trauma makes available, brings back lost objects to the consciousness, in a psychoanalytical sense. is then the digital archive an absolute oblivion<span clss='qstn'>?span>
<smlbrkr stl="display:block;white-space:nowrap;margin-bottom:-1em;overflow:hidden;">...................................smlbrkr>
///////// newer notes, saved in 11 ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>September 2016 /////////
<smlbrkr stl="display:block;white-space:nowrap;margin-bottom:-1em;overflow:hidden;">...................................smlbrkr>
ss='lgc'>[as ss="ppl">Holderlin announces that the “remains” for which s clss="trms">poes>ts are s clss="trms">respons>sible.ss='lgc'>]ss='lgc'>-ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">mems>ory (don't let engineers build you archives! let the s clss="trms">poes>t be s clss="trms">respons>sible for whatever has “remained.”) ss='lgc'>[this would be ss="ppl">Holderlinian advicess='lgc'>]
<span clss="prgrph">-inappropriable remainder(s)
span>
s clss="trms">mems>ory/res clss="trms">mems>ber is sojourn
the importance of archive is today perhaps not in creating one but in s clss="trms"nttrm="already,spread">reads>ing them.
ss='lgc'>--how many archive we still need to s clss="trms"nttrm="already,spread">reads> and probe and consider, with concepts or para-concepts that we thought we had a hold on.
<smlbrkr stl="display:block;white-space:nowrap;margin-bottom:-1em;overflow:hidden;">...................................smlbrkr>
being ens clss="trms">folds>ed is often a strategy for survival (<span clss='qstn'>?span>, ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Marks)
(ss="ppl">Akira Mizuta ss="ppl">Lippitss='lgc'>:) things are not saved by being archived (Borgesian nightmare)
s clss="trms">histos>ries for which the s clss="trms">presens>t is not s clss="trms"nttrm="already,spread">reads>y ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> what are those sites where s clss="trms">histos>ries slip into latency<span clss='qstn'>?span>
(how not<span clss='qstn'>?span>) <strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls>to enter a culture from outside<strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls> (problem of the prophet, both Moses and ss="ppl">Freud) ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>everything depends on the ways we ‘bring’ things<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls> ss='lgc'>[bringing monotheism, destruction, etc.ss='lgc'>] ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>~-> (s clss="trms">socis>al and s clss="trms">materis>al) milieu thinking (ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> to think about Baten in Baten)
(art's will and the judgment of value that informs it...) Kunstwollen's desire to grow and s clss="trms">traves>l
<smlbrkr stl="display:block;white-space:nowrap;margin-bottom:-1em;overflow:hidden;">...................................smlbrkr>
ss='lgc'>[ss="ppl">Ariella ss="ppl">Azoulayss='lgc'>]
() the ops clss="trms">posits>ion between keeping and putting away, preservation and cancelation.
archivess='lgc'>: the home of the dialectic of preservation and cancellation
...when fully lit and relatively flat
ss="ppl">Derridass='lgc'>: (archive) “is a s clss="trms">questions> of the future, the s clss="trms">questions> of the future itself, the s clss="trms">questions> of a s clss="trms">respons>se, of a promise and of a s clss="trms">respons>sibility for tomorrow.”
archive's ss="ppl">Foucauldian “space of appearance”
constructed as ex-territorial and as a receptacle (makhzan) for the s clss="trms">pasts>
archive is not a fortress external to our s clss="trms">worlds>, with us as its pilgrims
(the s clss="trms">ontos>logical performance of filling a document)
(a constellation, aimed at distancing and disturbing us)
collecting ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> grouping
extracting ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> sharing
cataloguing ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> indexing and tagging
<smlbrkr stl="display:block;white-space:nowrap;margin-bottom:-1em;overflow:hidden;">...................................smlbrkr>
(for ss="ppl">Freudss='lgc'>:) trauma <ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>~=> s clss="trms">mems>ory
(for ss="ppl">Nietzschess='lgc'>:) “Man could never do without blood, torture, and sacrifices when he felt the need to create a s clss="trms">mems>ory for himself.” ss='lgc'>-ss='lgc'>-ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> ‘ritual’ may be seen as a way to keep s clss="trms">mems>ory alive without the experience of pain<span clss='qstn'>?span>
(ss="ppl">Bataille after ss="ppl">Nietzschess='lgc'>:) ‘sacredness’ss='lgc'>: the revelation of continuity through the death of a discontinuous being
within the political art domain the “I feel your pain” has s clss="trms">syms>pathetic currency. one is punished by drawing public attention to their pleasures
(I feel your pleasures ss='lgc'>=/=) “sense of pain” ss='lgc'>[an asset of the artistss='lgc'>] ss='lgc'>==establishesss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> awareness of the existence of the body
processing is largely parallel, while, attention is largely serial
disciplines of the s clss="trms">moderns> subject
(in artistic work the unsolved issue remiansss='lgc'>:) s clss="trms">techns>niques for/of the external control
<smlbrkr stl="display:block;white-space:nowrap;margin-bottom:-1em;overflow:hidden;">...................................smlbrkr>
ss='lgc'>[<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>ss='lgc'>] which spaciotemporal vectors are embeded in the archive, as a s clss="trms">moderns> feeling of arrow that thrusts forward s clss="trms">differens>tiating s clss="trms">pasts> from the future, “archaic” from the “advanced”<span clss='qstn'>?span>
ss='lgc'>[<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>ss='lgc'>] archive produces a “yesterday”
a ds clss="trms"nttrm="danger,stranger">angers>ous arrow of time that is constituted and announced
<span clss="prgrph">-how do we attend the s clss="trms">histos>ries of implication and attachment<span clss='qstn'>?span>
span>
futurity ss='lgc'>[aghebat s>عاقبتs>, (even) akherat s>اخرتs>ss='lgc'>], the promis of the archive
<smlbrkr stl="display:block;white-space:nowrap;margin-bottom:-1em;overflow:hidden;">...................................smlbrkr>
traumass='lgc'>: that which it won't tell its s clss="trms">storys> ss='lgc'>=/= total recall
how can s clss="trms">histos>ry tell<span clss='qstn'>?span>
s clss="trms">histos>ry, a compensatory device<span clss='qstn'>?span>
<smlbrkr stl="display:block;white-space:nowrap;margin-bottom:-1em;overflow:hidden;">...................................smlbrkr>
gist
s>جان کلامs>
s>مرادs>
ss='lgc'>[ss="ppl">Geoffrey ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bowkerss='lgc'>]
http://www.ics.uci.edu/ss='lgc'>~gbowker/forget.html
Grand s clss="trms">Histos>riographer, ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Sima Qin (1994 ss='lgc'>[ca 100BCss='lgc'>]), s clss="trms">writs>ing of the burning of the s clss="trms">books>s in 213BC, notes that the Chief Minister adviced the emperor thatss='lgc'>: Aall who possess s clss="trms">literas>ture such as the ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Songs, the Documents, and the sayings of the hundred schools should get rid of it without penalty. If they have not got rid of it a full thirty days after the order has reached them, they should be branded and sent to do forced labor on the walls. there should be exemption for s clss="trms">books>s concerned with medicine, pharmacy, divination by tortoise-shell and milfoil, the sowing of crops, and the planting of trees (31). In s clss="trms">respons>se to this, the Emperor ordered the famous burning of the s clss="trms">books>s - to s clss="trms">cites> Qinss='lgc'>: Athe First Emperor collected up and got rid of the ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Songs, the Documents, and the sayings of the hundred schools in order to make the people stupid and ensure that in all under Heaven there should be no rejection of the s clss="trms">presens>t by using the s clss="trms">pasts>. The clarification of laws and regulations and the settling of statutes and ordinances all stared with the First Emperor. He standardized documents.
(to think of) s clss="trms">mems>ory as a construction of the s clss="trms">presens>t
analyzing organizational s clss="trms">mems>ory
organizing analytical s clss="trms">mems>ory
s clss="trms">mems>orizing organizational analysis
ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> multifaceted s clss="trms">storiess> open to s clss="trms">inters>pretation ss='lgc'>=/= true/false facts
<strcls clss='strcls'>****strcls>res clss="trms">mems>beringss='lgc'>: an activity which carries with it its own context<strcls clss='strcls'>****strcls>
work on s clss="nms">ajayebs> and my ongoing commentary on archive and s clss="trms">mems>ory is part and parcel of the organizational theory
not to forget thatss='lgc'>:
sts clss="lsts lst1">•rediscovery is easier than res clss="trms">mems>bering
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•statistics ss='lgc'>--asss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> filtering mechanism ss='lgc'>--asss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> proactive forgetting
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•forgetting ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> change of identity ss='lgc'>['clean slate’ is very well known state to mysticism, ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> clearance(ss='lgc'>=<span clss='qstn'>?span> is to take away useless theory) and os clss="trms"nttrm="righ,rigo,riga,rigi,trig,rign">rigs>ins in s clss="trms">geomes>try - ss='at'>#ss="ppl">ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Serresss='lgc'>]
sts>
organizational forgetting ss='lgc'>--producing/maintainingss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> classification s clss="trms">syss>tems ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> move from heterogeneous forms of s clss="trms">mems>ory operating within multiple frameworks ss='lgc'>[like s clss="nms">ajayebs> s clss="trms">bestiars>iesss='lgc'>] to the privileging of a form of s clss="trms">mems>ory (potential s clss="trms">mems>ory) operating within a well-defined information infrastructure subtended by classification s clss="trms">syss>tems. (ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bowker)
if your work is an s clss="trms">inters>mediary profession invisible and removed at the earliest opportunity from the official record, create a “ss='lgc'>[name of your practicess='lgc'>]-ing s clss="trms">inters>ventions classification” (<span clss='qstn'>?span>!) ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> a fascinating s clss="trms">syss>tem that creates a standardized s clss="trms">languages> for describing what is it that your practice does in s clss="trms">differens>t or difficult ways
other s clss="trms">syss>tems (to organize and critique your accumulation of experience)ss='lgc'>:
sts clss="lsts lst1">•sensitive outcomes classification scheme
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•diagnosis scheme
sts>
<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>sometimes what you do does not need to leave a trace, like nursing (in which your duty is to res clss="trms">mems>ber for others) ss='lgc'>[a professions without form ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>~ss='lgc'>~> nothing can be preserved, s clss="trms">cods>ing s clss="trms">pasts> knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> and linking it to current practicess='lgc'>ss='lgc'>---in the context of the hospital's s clss="trms">socis>os clss="trms">techns>ical s clss="trms">syss>temss='lgc'>], or cleaning ss='lgc'>[doing everything that nobody else doesss='lgc'>], or s clss="trms">storys>telling ss='lgc'>[you have to go to a new country every day, going to a foreign zonesss='lgc'>], or certain kinds of performances ss='lgc'>[ss='at'>@s clss="frds scrmbld">Ariannas> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> the intensity, focus, and complexity of caress='lgc'>], ss='lgc'>[going from being expert to novicess='lgc'>], and many times not s clss="trms">cods>able into discrete units of work practice to be carried out on s clss="trms">specifis>c occasions
in my hypertext s clss="trms">writs>ing, am i trying to enable myself to talk about <span clss='mywrk'>my workspan> in a s clss="trms">languages> that computers could understand<span clss='qstn'>?span>
(do we need<span clss='qstn'>?span>) to get at (and maintain<span clss='qstn'>?span>) the deep structure of the one's s clss="trms">situs>ation
ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> transformational grammar
ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> bring intuitive decision-making to a conscious level
ss='at'># the issue of the validity or not of s clss="nms">ajayebs>'s knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> is entirely orthogonal to my purpose. I am producing an anatomy of what it has meant in the case of s clss="trms">bestiars>y s clss="trms">writs>ing to create such a s clss="trms">scies>nce
(my issue with) ss='lgc'>[<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>ss='lgc'>]strategyss='lgc'>: a way of managing a s clss="trms">pasts> that threatens to grow out of control
(in working with s clss="trms">bestiars>ies <span clss='mywrk'>my researchspan> s clss="trms">questions>ss='lgc'>:) what could provide for a good ordering of s clss="trms">mems>ory<span clss='qstn'>?span>
<span clss="prgrph">-(which professions act as) distributed s clss="trms">mems>ory s clss="trms">syss>tem (for who<span clss='qstn'>?span>)
span>
<span clss="prgrph">-(what blocks between) s clss="trms">inters>nal s clss="trms">mems>ory and external s clss="trms">mems>ory ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> the time needed to work complex res clss="trms">presens>tations
span>
(we are trying to) s clss="trms">situs>ate our activity visibly within an informationalss='lgc'>[<span clss='qstn'>?span><strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>ss='lgc'>] s clss="trms">worlds> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> to be factored
<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>in an informational s clss="trms">worlds>ss='lgc'>: accountabilityss='lgc'> = s clss="trms">meass>urable, s clss="trms">finits>e, packaged, ss='lgc'><ss='lgc'>--<span clss='not'>✕span>ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> (other modes of) invisible and s clss="trms">articulats>ion work
...when s clss="trms">techns>icians/artists seeking new ways of s clss="trms">writs>ing (s clss="trms">scies>ntific/s clss="trms">poes>tic) papers so that their work gets acknowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>d ss='lgc'>==(and yet)ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> the s clss="trms">naturs>e of their (s clss="trms">scies>ntific/artistic) truth is not impeached<strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls>
ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> and sometimes we restructure our work so that (organizational, informational or truth-related) challenges will not be necessary ss='lgc'>-ss='lgc'>-ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> (at the end of the day there will be ss='lgc'>[always<span clss='qstn'>?span>ss='lgc'>] an) information infrastructure for the kind of work which contains an account of your activity ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> “informational panoptica” (ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bowker)
the classification s clss="trms">syss>tems we are giving to embed in the tools and reports we give in s clss="nms">apasss>
(in s clss="nms">apasss> problematically we are asked to) copy the transparency of our activity from one res clss="trms">presens>tational space (s clss="trms">inters>nal s clss="trms">mems>ory, nomenclature, s clss="trms">pasts> events, paper) to another (computerized record, giving a talk, time-framing) (ss='lgc'>=/= s clss="trms">contingens>cy) ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> an s clss="trms">ecologs>y of attention ss='lgc'>: <strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls>what can be forgotten and what should be res clss="trms">mems>bered<strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> development of (information) infrastructure
what is res clss="trms">mems>bered in the formal information s clss="trms">syss>tems ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> s clss="trms">ontos>logy of that s clss="trms">syss>tem
...recorded on a form; and forms necessarily impose/s clss="trms">naturs>alize classification s clss="trms">syss>tems (through the form's speed, rhythm, dimension, and how its s clss="trms">specifis>cations are implemented) <strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls>
(how am i working this in my pop-up s clss="trms">books> and hypertex<span clss='qstn'>?span> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> classification scheme of relevant events for <span clss='mywrk'>my researchspan>)
<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>informational space is (sufficiently well) pre-structured ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> some things/details can be assumed or are dropped out of the res clss="trms">presens>tational space
<span clss="prgrph">-in my pop-up s clss="trms">books> i am ens clss="trms">cods>ing a kind of s clss="trms">mems>ory in an organizational file ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==><span clss='qstn'>?span> “potential s clss="trms">mems>ory” (ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>~= possible future reconstructions) ss='lgc'><ss='lgc'>-- rejecting the ways in which s clss="trms">mems>ory is structured in the organization named s clss="nms">Irans>, or Middle East, or Germany, or Europe,
span>
needed for development of potential s clss="trms">mems>oryss='lgc'>:
sts clss="lsts lst1">•(forms of) erasure of local context ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> to some degree this is always done
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•(forms of) classification s clss="trms">syss>tem ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> computerized, s clss="trms">affects>ual, or s clss="trms">materis>ally textured s clss="trms">categs>ories
sts>
<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls> construction is always reconstruction <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>
artificial s clss="trms">mems>ory (characteristic of the 16th centuryss='lgc'>:) “a search for the perfectly proportioned image containing the ‘soul’ of the knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> to be res clss="trms">mems>bered” ss='lgc'>--toss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> discovery of the s clss="trms"nttrm="righ,rigo,riga,rigi,trig,rign">rigs>ht logical s clss="trms">categs>ory ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> classifying the s clss="trms">mems>orization the s clss="trms">worlds> s clss="trms">scies>ntifically
classification s clss="trms">syss>tem ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> filter ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> ens clss="trms">cods>ing (of information about the environment) ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> coherent frameworkss='lgc'> = s clss="trms">mems>ory (ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Schachter, 1996)
ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bowker > Matsuda > Edouard Claparede's experiment (1907) of having a strs clss="trms"nttrm="danger,stranger">angers> rush into the classroom, do something outrageous, and then have students describe what happened ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> “that the s clss="trms">pasts>ss='lgc'>--even of a simple eventss='lgc'>--was less a record than a s clss="trms">sorts> of taxonomy. Not perceptions, but s clss="trms">categs>orization of familiar types was the major function of s clss="trms">mems>ory”
ss='at'>#bambi
pigeonholing of facts
how s clss="nms">apasss> as an organizations is s clss="trms">cods>ing for artistic research within the framework of their s clss="trms">mems>ory s clss="trms">syss>tems<span clss='qstn'>?span>
“There is no room on the ss='lgc'>[fillingss='lgc'>] form to s clss="trms">writs>e an essay on race identity politics.”
do we need to develop and standardize my discipline-s clss="trms">specifis>c nomenclature (in our research micros clss="trms">worlds>) in order to name without ambiguity<span clss='qstn'>?span> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> redes clss="trms">finits>ion of disciplinary boundaries ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> shaping of your work so that its future practice converges on potential s clss="trms">mems>ory
we murder, they note
they draw from their secretss='lgc'>[sss='lgc'>]
infrastructure-thinkingss='lgc'>: Ajayeb s clss="trms">Networks>-Making Minimum s clss="trms">Datas> ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Set
in s clss="nms">ajayebs>'s s clss="trms">literas>ture the very information infrastructure itself (should let be or) is in flux ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> discourses make strange connections between themselves
<span clss="prgrph">-in s clss="nms">ajayebs> the infrastructure assumes the s clss="trms">posits>ion of every node ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> reworked in my ss='at'>#s clss="trms"nttrm="righ,rigo,riga,rigi,trig,rign">Rigs>s
span>
“...we are afloat in a sea of multiple, fractured s clss="trms">causas>lities each s clss="trms">demands>ing their own classification s clss="trms">syss>temsss='lgc'>--and their own s clss="trms">apparatuss> of record collection.” (ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bowker)
classification (s clss="trms">syss>tems)ss='lgc'>: a warrant and a tool for forgetting, and operating the distribution of this forgetting (in space of s clss="trms">scies>ntific s clss="trms">mems>ory.)
it tells you what to forget (for example the s clss="trms">religs>ious and s clss="trms">s clss="trms"nttrm="metaph,metamorph,metabol,metal">metas>physs>ical,) and how to forget it
ss='lgc'>[the formation (training) of artists covers up the formation (production) of artistic knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>ss='lgc'>]
<span clss="prgrph">-the s clss="trms">socis>al s clss="trms">storys> of s clss="trms">scies>nce is exs clss="trms"nttrm="cluster,club">clus>ded from the organization of the s clss="trms">scies>nces, and held outside of it ss='lgc'>=/= s clss="trms">situs>ated knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>
span>
<span clss="prgrph">-a s clss="trms">naturs>al hierarchy of s clss="trms">scies>nces is offeredss='lgc'>: every discipline needs to res clss="trms">mems>ber only a given set of facts ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> each type of s clss="trms">mems>ory which has been distributed in space will also be sequenced in time (http://s clss="nms">ajayebs>.net/<span clss='qstn'>?span>q=imperativess='lgc'>+ofss='lgc'>+knowing) ss='lgc'>[ss='thdf'>for example mathematics ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> physics ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> chemistry ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> biology ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">socis>ologyss='lgc'>] ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> formal s clss="trms">mems>ory s clss="trms">syss>tem
span>
the problem of the detective is that for him only those facts are relevant that hand him the solution of crime (ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>~-> goal-oriented individual diss clss="trms">posits>ion) ss='lgc'>=/= chasing rabbits
<span clss="prgrph">-the detective (has to) classify away tracesss='lgc'>: the s clss="trms">syss>tematic and deliberate forgetting of some actions in order to better res clss="trms">mems>ber others
span>
<span clss="prgrph">-what makes a s clss="trms">differens>ce<span clss='qstn'>?span>
span>
<span clss="prgrph">-in s clss="trms">sorts>ing s clss="trms">animals>s which s clss="trms">pasts> knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>s (ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="nms">ajayebs>) are deliberatly forgotten in order to res clss="trms">mems>ber them as incorporated into an information infrastructure called ‘s clss="trms">species>s’<span clss='qstn'>?span> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>-->! the classified are res clss="trms">mems>bered (in the s clss="trms">techns>os clss="trms">scies>nce s clss="trms">worlds>)
span>
(what is the) complex s clss="trms">ecologs>y of s clss="trms">mems>ory practices (particular within s clss="nms">apasss><span clss='qstn'>?span>)
sts clss="lsts lst1">•s clss="frds scrmbld">Hodas> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> politics of res clss="trms">mems>brance
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•s clss="frds scrmbld">Zoumanas> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">situs>ated perspective
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•s clss="frds">ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Sinas> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">narrats>able s clss="trms">pasts>
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•s clss="frds scrmbld">Marialenas> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> type of s clss="trms">languages>
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>S
sts>
today, 18.07.2017, the s clss="nms">ajayebs>'s knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> can be stored and expressed in a quite restricted range of genres called myth, ancient, s clss="trms">imagis>nary,
______________
http://www.ics.uci.edu/ss='lgc'>~gbowker/records.html
we have learned from ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Foucault that s clss="trms">differens>t (medical) records, s clss="trms">differens>t practices of s clss="trms"nttrm="already,spread">reads>ing and s clss="trms">writs>ing are s clss="trms">inters>twined with the production of s clss="trms">differens>t patient's bodies, body politic, and bodies of knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>
ss='at'>@Olga
record is the s clss="trms">storys> of the organizational infrastructure ss='lgc'>[ss='at'>@s clss="frds scrmbld">Marialenas>, Olgass='lgc'>]
ss='lgc'>[ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Foucault on knowing in the practice of medicine:ss='lgc'>] cascade of inscriptions ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">writs>ing ss='lgc'>[ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> totality of observers/observations ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> “true knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>"ss='lgc'>] ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">moderns> clinical gaze ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> pathological processes of individual bodies (ss='lgc'>=/= medicine of s clss="trms">species>sss='lgc'>: individual s clss="trms">syms>ptoms / medical knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>, essential truth beneath the sensible individuality)
...a body which hides the essences of the disease ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> production of the organizations which enact and treat it
How is the patient (or choreographic) body's s clss="trms">specifis>c s clss="trms">geomes>try and its s clss="trms">histos>ricity created<span clss='qstn'>?span>
<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>body is produced through s clss="trms">embods>ied, s clss="trms">materis>ally heterogeneous work
(ss="ppl">Foucauldian) diss clss="trms">posits>ifss='lgc'>: a s clss="trms">networks> within which the body acquires its s clss="trms">specifis>c s clss="trms">ontos>logy
(ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Latour < ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bowkerss='lgc'>:) the record ‘mediates’ the s clss="trms">relations>s that it organizes, the bodies that are configured through it
regarding record, we can be concerned withss='lgc'>:
sts clss="lsts lst1">•practices of s clss="trms"nttrm="already,spread">reads>ing and s clss="trms">writs>ing which bring the record to life
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•mapping the cons clss="trms">figurats>ions the record helps bring into being
sts>
how the structuring of the record speaks to the structuring of the bodies (of the artists<span clss='qstn'>?span>) we investigate<span clss='qstn'>?span> (ss='at'>@s clss="frds scrmbld">ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Sofias>, Olga)
record ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>-->ss='lgc'>{
production of human bodies
organizational hierarchies
selective s clss="trms">mems>ories
_________
Ribes ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bowker - Between Meaning and Machine.pdf
...in the wake of s clss="trms">ontos>logies
in participating in knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> projects, first we learn about s clss="trms">ontos>logies and then learned how to create them
(we rarely “produce” knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>, we always participate)
s clss="trms">ontos>logyss='lgc'>: an information s clss="trms">techns>ology for res clss="trms">presens>ting specialized knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> in order toss='lgc'>:
sts clss="lsts lst1">•facilitate s clss="trms">communs>ication across disciplines
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•share s clss="trms">datas>
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•enable collaboration
sts>
(am i) res clss="trms">presens>ting the knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> of my s clss="trms">communs>ities (<span clss='qstn'>?span>) ss='lgc'>-- what does that mean<span clss='qstn'>?span>
<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>s clss="trms">routins>ization<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls> (is that which is at stake in s clss="trms">ontos>logies) ss='lgc'>--<span clss='qstn'>?span>ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>apprehension<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>ss='lgc'>: orientation to the informational organization of ones field
(to attend the s clss="trms">routins>izations and apprehensions in one's own practice ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">ontos>logy building)
sts clss="lsts lst1">•my s clss="trms">routins>es of s clss="trms"nttrm="already,spread">reads>ing, highlighting, s clss="trms">writs>ing, idios clss="trms">syncs>ratic talks, feedbacks, s clss="trms">questions>s, silences,
sts>
ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> (attend to the) transformative consequences of learning and s clss="trms">traves>rsing s clss="trms">routins>es ss='lgc'>--ss='lgc'>[ss='lgc'>+ss='lgc'>]ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> the practice and s clss="trms">materis>al tools that accompany the reworking of them ss='lgc'>{knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> in informational terms, s clss="trms">fables>s, etc.ss='lgc'>}ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> problematic of s clss="trms">inters>-operability
ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> (and asking) how a (broader) s clss="trms">communs>ity's s clss="trms">inters>ests are at stake with this<span clss='qstn'>?span> ss='lgc'>{to engage and enrol that s clss="trms">communs>ity through what activities<span clss='qstn'>?span>ss='lgc'>} ss='at'>#micros clss="trms">worlds>
ss="large lg14" stl="font-size:119%">
(my s clss="trms">routins>esss='lgc'>:) with confidence deliberately working withss='lgc'>:
sts clss="lsts lst1">•s clss="trms">inters>rupting s clss="trms">storiess> with s clss="trms">storiess>
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•partial connection (and its performance)
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•moving arguments through by infecting them with other arguments (ss='lgc'>=/= dialectical)
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•mobilizing (multidisciplinary) fields (ss='lgc'>=/= the imperative of knowing A, B, and C first before you do D)
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•mobilizing s clss="trms">citas>tion s clss="trms">apparatuss> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> that which gives sense to what enables this work ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> deliberately having a conversation with s clss="nms">s clss="nms">ajayebs> al makhlughats>
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•mobilizing anachronic s clss="trms">apparatuss> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> mobilizing s clss="trms">differens>t timescales ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> mixing up what counts as “us” (ss='lgc'>=/= chronology ss='lgc'>[<span clss='qstn'>?span>ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> belongingss='lgc'>])
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•res clss="trms">mems>bering what one knows (and organizing, performing, reworking it)
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•having stakes in rationality (i constantly criticize rationality, but as you can see, i am not at all throwing it out)
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•omnivorous approach
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•
sts>
s clss="trms">wilds> facts amenable (s>تابعs>) to formal res clss="trms">presens>tation (formal modeling)
s clss="trms">routins>ess='lgc'>: practically enacted, having no existence outside its performance, embedded in the cons clss="trms">figurats>ion of s clss="trms">materis>al resources that enable practical work
ss='lgc'>[ss='at'>#workshop s clss="trms">fables>sss='lgc'>] how, by s clss="trms">traves>rsing the s clss="trms">routins>e, “knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>” and “s clss="trms">communs>ity” took on new meaning, as they were res clss="trms">articulats>ed in the s clss="trms">differens>t s clss="trms">languages>s
uncertain activities of knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>
(what i am learning in s clss="nms">apasss> is that) modeling s clss="trms">ontos>logies involves s clss="trms">articulats>ing knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> in ways that sometimes appears alien to that domain s clss="trms">communs>ity
ss='lgc'>[asking with ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bowker:ss='lgc'>] for my s clss="trms">ontos>logy-building to appear res clss="trms">presens>tative, does my s clss="trms">communs>ity itself have to learn the goals and s clss="trms">languages> of my knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> modeling<span clss='qstn'>?span> (the s clss="trms">questions> i asked s clss="frds scrmbld">ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Svens>, telling others ‘this or that is the s clss="trms">languages> i am using.’) (i am using a s clss="trms">languages> that is ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Harawayian, ss="ppl">Ronellian, ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Sadrian)
______________
http://www.ics.uci.edu/ss='lgc'>~gbowker/actnet.html
...it is easy to get lost in ss="ppl">Baudrillard's cool s clss="trms">mems>ories of simulacra (1990)
at stakess='lgc'>: day to day work of building classification s clss="trms">syss>tem
things to learnd from actor-s clss="trms">networks> approachss='lgc'>: (ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Latour, Callon > ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bowker)
sts clss="lsts lst1">•regimes of delegation
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•centrality of mediation
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•the s clss="trms">posits>ion that s clss="trms">naturs>e and s clss="trms">socis>ety are not causes but consequences of human s clss="trms">scies>ntific and tachnical work
sts>
ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> “s clss="trms">techns>os clss="trms">scies>ntific s clss="trms">socis>eties are powerful precisely because they are so good at delegating and distributing; and that actor-s clss="trms">networks> theory is well s clss="trms">posits>ion to track and describe the work of delegation and distribution.”
fact is a consequence
(Dewey)
(in a way, <span clss='mywrk'>my workspan> and s clss="trms">inters>est in s clss="nms">ajayebs> is about s clss="trms">histos>ries of standards in knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> production, which, i argue, is key to all s clss="trms">sorts>s of other productions) (& the politics of res clss="trms">mems>brance ss='lgc'>: the politics and philosophy of classifying certain textual/s clss="trms">materis>al activities such that they have a chance of being part of the cultural <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>potential<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls> s clss="trms">mems>ory)ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>-->ss='lgc'>{Olga, s clss="frds scrmbld">Hodas>, s clss="frds scrmbld">ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Sanas>ss='lgc'>}
artists are using a lot of standards (of res clss="trms">presens>tations or s clss="trms">materis>als)
(out of) control standards
<span clss="prgrph">-there is a huge amount of standards i am depending on in my hypertext
span>
<span clss="prgrph">-s clss="trms">inters>national diplomacy depends on manufacturing and enforcement of standard s clss="trms">vocabulars>y ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> how much are we really in diplomatic businesses<span clss='qstn'>?span>
span>
Googless='lgc'>: “To organize the s clss="trms">worlds>'s information and make it universally accessible and useful”
standards are oftenss='lgc'>:
sts clss="lsts lst1">•making things work together
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•enforced by legal bodies
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•have their own (significant) inertia ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> hard to change, and is not about the s clss="trms">techns>ically superior standards winning ss='lgc'>[DOss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>S, VHss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>S, A4, etc.ss='lgc'>]
sts>
standards ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>aspect of acting in the s clss="trms">worlds><strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> classifications
what are (or have been) the behind the ss clss="trms">cenes>s, boring, background processes of the “real” work of s clss="nms">ajayebs> (and any s clss="trms">pasts> and practical politics of knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> production)<span clss='qstn'>?span> (ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> becoming s clss="trms">inters>ested in a wider scope of s clss="trms"nttrm="already,spread">reads>ingss='lgc'>: s clss="trms">rhetors>ics, s clss="trms">semios>tics, objectivity, analysis, architecture,)
sts clss="lsts lst1">•s clss="trms">histos>rically creation of the infrastructure
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•ubiquity and webbed saturation of classifying and standardizing
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•s clss="trms">materis>ally textured (layered, tangled)
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•their negotiated s clss="trms">naturs>e
sts>
<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>distribution of s clss="trms">mems>ory (and distribution of res clss="trms">presens>tation)ss='lgc'>:
X ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">histos>rical s clss="trms">contingens>cies ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> a s clss="trms">narrats>ive ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> practical politics ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> standard s clss="trms">narrats>ive ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> universal s clss="trms">categs>ory ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> erases its own s clss="trms">narrats>ological s clss="trms">pasts>, (employed s clss="trms">inters>nallyss='lgc'>+externally) deletion of modalities in the development of (s clss="trms">scies>ntific) texts; ss='lgc'>[a modality can be deleted in a number of s clss="trms">differens>t waysss='lgc'>: ss='lgc'>[<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>ss='lgc'>] it might be distributed (held in another part of the organization than in that which produces the text), ss='lgc'>[<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>ss='lgc'>] built into the infrastructure (the work environment is changed such that the modality is never encountered), etc. ss='lgc'>=/= ss='at'>#accountabilityss='lgc'>] ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> fact (ss='lgc'>+ single s clss="trms">articulats>ion, only one plot of s clss="trms">datas>) ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> mobilizing a set of black-boxesss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>-->ss='lgc'>{s clss="frds scrmbld">Xiris>'s “queers,” s clss="frds scrmbld">Eszters>'s “participants,”ss='lgc'>: what goes inside these black-boxes and how they look like, is seen as irrelevant for them. ss='lgc'>[ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">translats>ing from the context of storage to the s clss="trms">presens>t s clss="trms">situs>ation (one might store a fact for reason X but recall it for reason Y) ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Latour ss='lgc'>+ ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bowkerss='lgc'>]ss='lgc'>}
X ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> indeterminacy <span clss='and'>&span> multiplicity ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> conflict ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> negotiations ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> standard
where to make the cuts in the s clss="trms">syss>tem, for example, down to what level of detail one s clss="trms">specifis>es a description of work, of an illness, of a setting, ss='lgc'>[of an s clss="trms">animals>, of a queerness, of a subjectivity, and so on.ss='lgc'>]
residual s clss="trms">categs>ories ss='lgc'>{rest, others, miscellaneous,ss='lgc'>} are ubiquitous
what are the mismatches between subs clss="trms">syss>tems in s clss="nms">ajayebs> and Qur'an<span clss='qstn'>?span>
ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> “cumulative mess s clss="trms">trajects>ory” (ss="ppl">ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Strauss) ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> when the s clss="trms">trajects>ories become so tangled that you can't return and the s clss="trms">inters>actions multiply
we are riding on s clss="trms">s clss="trms"nttrm="metaph,metamorph,metabol,metal">metas>phors>es to move in a s clss="trms">denss>ely classified s clss="trms">worlds>
“There is no way of ever getting access to the s clss="trms">pasts> except through classification s clss="trms">syss>tems of one s clss="trms">sorts> or another - formal or informal, hierarchical or not” ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bowker
sts clss="lsts lst1">•“in the 14th century” ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> segmentation of time, s clss="trms">syss>tem of calendar
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•“s clss="nms">Irans>ian” ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> discourse of national genius only arose in the 19th century
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•“revolution” ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> our current conception of ‘revolution’ is marked by the s clss="trms">histos>riographical work of Karl ss="ppl">Marx
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•(s clss="trms">histos>riographical traditions)
sts>
compare first lines of Halaj's biography in ss="ppl">Attar and Wikipediass='lgc'>:
sts clss="lsts lst1">•s>آن فی الله فی سبیل الله آن شیر بیشه تحقیق آن شجاع صفدر صدیق آن غرقه دریای مواج حسین منصور حلاج رحمةالله علیه کار او کاری عجب بود و واقعات غرایب که خاص او را بود که هم در غایت سوز و اشتیاق بود و در شدت لهب و فراق مست و بیقرار و شوریده روزگار بود و عاشق صادق و پاک باز و جد وجهدی عظیم داشت و ریاضتی و کرامتی عجب و عالی همت و رفیع قدر بود او را تصانیف بسیار استs> ss='lgc'>[...ss='lgc'>]
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•Mansur al-Hallaj (ss="ppl">Arabicss='lgc'>: Abū ‘l-Muġīṭ Al-Ḥusayn bin Manṣūr al-Ḥallāğ; Persianss='lgc'>: Mansūr-e Ḥallāj) (c. 858 – 26 March 922) (Hijri c. 244 AH – 309 AH) was a Persian mystic, s clss="trms">poes>t and teacher of ss='trgt hghlght 1'href='?q=S'>Sufism ss='lgc'>[...ss='lgc'>]
sts>
(at the end it is the colonialism that) decides what a disease is ss='lgc'>[ss='lgc'>=/= other s clss="trms">syss>tem/culture (fragile s clss="trms">networks>s) for classifying diseases of the body and spirit, such as s clss="nms">ajayebs>. (for example see how s clss="trms">schizos>phrenia is classified and understood)ss='lgc'>]
ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> practical s clss="trms">ontos>logy
res clss="trms">presens>tation of the s clss="trms">pasts>
sequencing of the s clss="trms">presens>t
ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> making it appear that s clss="trms">scies>nce describes s clss="trms">naturs>e ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">socis>al power
(at the end you see only those actants who are strong enough, and shaped in the s clss="trms"nttrm="righ,rigo,riga,rigi,trig,rign">rigs>ht way, to impact)
“ss='lgc'>[...ss='lgc'>] the loosest classification of work is s clss="trms">accords>ed to those with the most power and discretion, who are able to set their own terms.” ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bowker 1996
s clss="trms">lingus>a franca of the medical insurance companies
actor s clss="trms">networks> theoryss='lgc'>: looking in detail at the role of (relatively) black-boxed hybrids ss='lgc'>[what s clss="trms">scies>ntists are actually manufacturingss='lgc'>] in creating the discourse of pure s clss="trms">scies>nce (as endpoint)
s clss="trms">scies>nce's objective account of s clss="trms">naturs>al orderss='lgc'>:
sts clss="lsts lst1">•trials of strength
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•enrolling of allies
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•cascades of inscriptions
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•operation of immutable mobiles
sts>
ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> development of standards
‘Janus face’ of s clss="trms">scies>nce
ss='lgc'>[Janus, in ancient Roman is the god of beginnings, gates, s clss="trms">transits>ions, time, duality, doorways, passages, and endings. a god of s clss="trms">transits>ions. having two faces, he looks to the future and to the s clss="trms">pasts>. (s clss="trms">Greeks>s had no equivalent to Janus.)ss='lgc'>]
when your work (artistic/s clss="trms">scies>ntific) can be seen as a direct s clss="trms">translats>ion of the quest for s clss="nms">Irans>ian/French honor after defeat in the battlefield ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> the actors don't see what is exs clss="trms"nttrm="cluster,club">clus>dedss='lgc'>: they construct a s clss="trms">worlds> in which that exs clss="trms">s clss="trms"nttrm="cluster,club">clus>sis>on could occur
(ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Latour ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">accords>ing to American s clss="trms">pragmas>tist strongholdsss='lgc'>:) realityss='lgc'> = 'that which resists’
common s clss="trms">languages> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>~= standard s clss="trms">languages>
(we can't talk about the commons without s clss="trms">sorts>ing out our understanding of our standard-saturated s clss="trms">worlds>)
(my hypertext is not s clss="trms">datas>-driven ss='lgc'>[= a s clss="trms">syss>tem with focus on the acquisition, management, processing, and s clss="trms">presens>tation of ‘atomic-level’ s clss="trms">datas>ss='lgc'>] nor a process-driven (or process-sensitive s clss="trms">syss>tem, for example delivering a care), what is it then<span clss='qstn'>?span>) (also not s clss="trms">syss>tematically storing ss='lgc'>[myss='lgc'>] “knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges>” for later access, storage of information in such long-term s clss="trms">mems>ory, no no no)
<span clss="prgrph">-is it a support for my various tasks and practices outside the computer<span clss='qstn'>?span> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> s clss="trms">excesss>-driven s clss="trms">storys>tellings ss='lgc'>=/= minimum s clss="trms">datas> set
span>
<span clss="prgrph">-a non-s clss="trms">datas>-driven s clss="trms">syss>tems in this s clss="trms">socis>ety are named secretive and mysterious in the name of transparency
span>
ss='at'>#in a way i am building an adequate mode of encounter with the “s clss="nms">Irans>ian s clss="trms">scies>ntist”
they draw from their secretss='lgc'>[sss='lgc'>]
a s clss="trms">techns>ical issue (for example about how to s clss="trms">cods>e process) is also a an organizational theory
s clss="trms">socis>al embeddedness of s clss="trms">scies>ntific truth
(s clss="trms">authors>s of s clss="nms">ajayebs> approached s clss="trms">naturs>e not in a way to sketch the boundaries of a discrete s clss="trms">animals> event, therefore, a unit of analysis, (which is very s clss="trms">naturs>al at 21st century;) rather an infrastructure itself in flux, providing an uns clss="trms">naturs>al hierarchy)ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> this is my s clss="trms">rhetors>ical s clss="trms"nttrm="already,spread">reads>ing of s clss="nms">ajayebs>
as long as you/God pays attention to them, they will continue to exist
‘uninventing X’ss='lgc'>: changing s clss="trms">socis>ety and s clss="trms">techns>ology in such a way that the X becomes an impossibility. (Donald Mackenzie)
development and maintenance of s clss="trms">techns>ical standards is a site of political decisions and struggle
______________
against ss='thdf'>the idea that “s clss="trms">pasts> is a s clss="trms">differens>t country, they do things s clss="trms">differens>tly there”
<strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls>how we are creating s clss="trms">differens>t kinds of s clss="trms">pasts> (out of the information infrastructures that we build)<span clss='qstn'>?span>
(pointed out by ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bowker) the whole notion of big s clss="trms">datas> is coming from the invention of census (amar-giri s>آمارگیریs>) in late 18th century, as its predecessor in a genealogy of s clss="trms">techns>iques of government. “big s clss="trms">datas> is grown up around that idea of control” ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> statisticsss='lgc'>: (etymologically) the s clss="trms">scies>nce of the state<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>
“I” ss='lgc'><ss='lgc'>== me ss='lgc'>+ my s clss="trms">datas>
heavily informated s clss="trms">worlds>
flashbulb s clss="trms">mems>ory<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>
‘what were you doing when ss='at'>#s clss="nms">Bambis>'s mother got shot<span clss='qstn'>?span>’ people have vivid but 80<span clss='prcnt'>%span> of the time wronge s clss="trms">mems>ories of that day ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> we are good at creating certainty in s clss="trms">mems>ory, but not very good at recognizing the ways s clss="trms">pasts> is s clss="trms">differens>tly configured s clss="trms">accords>ing to s clss="trms">differens>t kinds of <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>s clss="trms">mems>ory practice<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>
the eternal flame file type/format
the psychoanalyst of Tintin
active archiving is about the framing of the s clss="trms">presens>t, and not about the future record
<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>coms clss="trms">mems>oration is behind a lot of the ways in which we create s clss="trms">mems>ories and s clss="trms">histos>ries (on the web)ss='lgc'>: that there will be someone who has the time to go back and recognize the values we have created ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> recognize ourselves as monuments in the s clss="trms">worlds>
(thinking with ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Bowker fL94LVYjhQQ) as new entities will come to being in the s clss="trms">worlds>, instead of creating access to what is reconfiguring of the s clss="trms">pasts> we lock ourselves into single unitary visions of the s clss="trms">pasts> totally unnecessary ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> that is exactly what i am trying to do, providing and creating a kind of approach to what would be an access to a reconfiguring of the s clss="trms">pasts>, s clss="nms">ajayebs> as the case in a s clss="trms">Farsis> speaking s clss="trms">worlds>
on way or another, s clss="trms">datas>bases are structured objects, they constraint the forms of s clss="trms">narrats>ive you can take ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> a restrict set of s clss="trms">storiess> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> when we are dealing with s clss="trms">datas>base we don't have an ins clss="trms">finits>e sets of s clss="trms">narrats>ive space
i am taking a theological alterity discourse from pre-enlightenment (islamicated s clss="trms">cosmos>logy) and puting it in ss='lgc'>[...<span clss='qstn'>?span>ss='lgc'>]<strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls> (ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Latour is putting it in s clss="trms">scies>ntific style of faith)
sts clss="lsts lst1">•artistic research practices/discourses
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•s clss="trms">moderns> s clss="nms">Irans>
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•s clss="trms">moderns> culture
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•
sts>
non-contemplative intelligence basing the s clss="trms">datas>base in our time (ss='lgc'>=/= older traditions of sequencing)
ss="large lg30" stl="font-size:102%">
<smlbrkr stl="display:block;white-space:nowrap;margin-bottom:-1em;overflow:hidden;">...................................smlbrkr>
<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>deterioration of the immanent (eco-, politico-,) ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> corruption of s clss="trms">socis>al s clss="trms">relations>s ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> corruption of s clss="trms">mems>ory<strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls> (of a shared existence, of coexistence with ss='lgc'>[Div, jinn, shadow, s clss="trms">birds>s, Hindus, Arabs, ss='lgc'>]) !!!ss='lgc'>--<span clss='not'>✕span>ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> issues of s clss="trms">histos>rical injustice
<span clss="prgrph">-or-
span>
corruption of a river ss='lgc'>: the entropy and deterioration immanent to it ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> conditions of possibility for corruption of intimate s clss="trms">relations>s and of s clss="trms">mems>ory ss='lgc'>}ss='lgc'>--(ss='lgc'>[thisss='lgc'>] experience of corruption)ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> takes the s clss="trms">naturs>e of being defrauded (s>روزگار فريبکارs>) of one's own form of life, one's family or one's ins clss="trms">herits>ance<strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls>
(ss="ppl">Naveeda ss="ppl">Khan talking about river's point of view in Bangladesh, but her keywords are all relevant for s clss="nms">Irans>'s landscape as well)
<strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls>the muslim s clss="trms">respons>ses to entropy<strcls clss='strcls'>***strcls> ss='lgc'>==<span clss='qstn'>?span>ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> eschatology
ss='lgc'>}ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> muslim majority regions are more embeded in the s clss="trms">worlds> that what we know from islam
s>سازشs>
limits of “adaptation”
a rapport ss='lgc'>~ s>ربط تقریباً همگامs>
or orientation s>جهتگيرىs>
a looming future
“ss='lgc'>[howss='lgc'>] politics and policies of climate change stand to shortchange the s clss="trms">presens>t and the s clss="trms">pasts>”
ss="ppl">Naveeda ss="ppl">Khan exploring the perception of climate change within everyday life
those who live on such formations ss='lgc'>--ss='lgc'>[powerful river waters, eroding, accreting, village politics, dynamics of individual lives,ss='lgc'>]
fret s>ترش کردنs>
s>مزروعىs> arable lands
thinking riversss='lgc'>:
to consider water as a ‘total s clss="trms">socis>al fact’, to think hos clss="trms"nttrm="listen,alist,ilist,llist,olist,ylist,ulist">lists>ically about water ss='lgc'>[Caton <span clss='and'>&span> Ors clss="trms">lovs>ess='lgc'>] ss='lgc'>=/= ss='lgc'>[ss="ppl">Naveeda'sss='lgc'>] climate thinking ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> that there is s clss="trms">specifis>city that needs attendingss='lgc'>: rivers are major conduits s>هادىs> of ‘connectivity’ ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> domain of localized s clss="trms">inters>actions
<span clss="prgrph">-to take the river to convey local, s clss="trms">embods>ied knowls clss="trms"nttrm="knowledge,Knowledge">edges> within the longer temporalities and emergent horizons (ass clss="trms">socis>ated with climate change,) (new global urgencies produced by climate thinking)
span>
a sufficient sense of the river
(Cavell < ss="ppl">Naveeda's) there-ness of the riverss='lgc'>: “the rivers are a distinctive and significant locale at which human beings, though not only human beings, find their dwelling place.” Cavell s clss="trms">respons>ds thus, “The river s clss="trms">poes>tizes the human being because, in providing <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>the unity of locality and journeying<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls> it conceals and reveals Dasein's being and becoming ‘homely,’ homelike, I might say, homebound.”
in an analytical approach to examine separately ss='lgc'>[that is ‘to model'ss='lgc'>]ss='lgc'>: narative actions and ss='lgc'>[-ianss='lgc'>] images
ss="ppl">ss="ppl">Marks’ understanding of film as conveying the corporeality of objects
ss='lgc'>[<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>ss='lgc'>]milieu
a powerful concept with genealogy across a range of disciplines ss='lgc'>[physics, biology, geography, s clss="trms">literas>ture ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> orienting our use of itss='lgc'>]
sts clss="lsts lst1">•18th centuryss='lgc'>: the fluid or ether in which physical bodies are immersed ss='lgc'>==(that enable their)ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> s clss="trms">inters>-dependence (ss='at'>#shena, shenavar<span clss='qstn'>?span>) ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> milieu becomes universal
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•19th centuryss='lgc'>: as producing circumstances that changes needs ss='lgc'>[Lamarckss='lgc'>] ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> for ss="ppl">Darwin milieu only produced change (at the level of the organism's phenotype)
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•milieu rendered as complexes of elements whose actions s clss="trms">mutuals>ly limit each other and in which the effects of causes become causes in turn, modifying the causes that gave rise to them. (ss="ppl">Canguilhem)
sts>
umweltss='lgc'>: organisms privilege certain stimuli and s clss="trms">respons>se, thus, sugs clss="trms">gests>ing to ss="ppl">Canguilhem that it isn't merely ‘need’ mediating between organism and milieu (as in Lamarck's s clss="trms">formus>lation) but a s clss="trms">priors> sense of values that evaluates certain signals as worthy of s clss="trms">respons>se over others
ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>the s clss="trms">animals> finds it simpler to do what it privileges<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls> (ss="ppl">Canguilhem 2008)
ss='lgc'>[<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>ss='lgc'>]sensess='lgc'>: (from the biological and psychological point of viewss='lgc'>:) an appreciation of values in s clss="trms">relations> to a ss='lgc'>[<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>ss='lgc'>]needss='lgc'>: (for the one who experuences and lives itss='lgc'>:) an irreducible ss='lgc'>==(thereby)ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>==> absolute, s clss="trms">syss>tem of reference
ss="ppl">Naveeda's notion of river's point of viewss='lgc'>:
“...” while the inorganic, such as a river, lacks the building blocks of life in being produced through the action of geological forces, it too has norms and values that take statistical form or are found (in both sense of the wordss='lgc'>: discovered and os clss="trms"nttrm="righ,rigo,riga,rigi,trig,rign">rigs>inating) in moments of spontaneous action (ss='lgc'>-ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> <span clss='gtrw'>go tospan> ss="ppl">Delandass='at'>#)
...village and kinship structures being flexible, there is a high value places on sexual normativity
absence of water ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> human suffering ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> the death of the river ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> emergence of land as property
ss="ppl">Naveeda examines 3 filmsss='lgc'>:
sts clss="lsts lst1">•focus on corruption, melodramatic s clss="trms">specifis>cities of the film-scale, subtext of pain ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> Titash Ekti Nodir Naam
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•focus on entropy within the Padma river, <strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls>ambivalent expression over the necessity for migration that will undoubtedly be one of the strategies of adaptation for an ocean-facing country such as Bangladesh<strcls clss='strcls'>*strcls> ss='lgc'>ss='lgc'>--> Padma Nodir Majhi
sts>
sts clss="lsts lst1">•(film's anticipation of) how s clss="trms">rumors>ssts>[...]